% ‘Icarus: The Aftermath’ Review: Oscar-Winning Doping Doc Gets Sequel IndieWire × Continue to IndieWire SKIP AD You will be redirected back to your article in seconds Back to IndieWire News All News Galleries Lists Box Office Trailers Festivals Thompson on Hollywood Film All Film Reviews Interviews Profiles of a Partnership 2022 Best Movies of 2022, So Far 2022 Fall Movie Preview 2023 Oscars ’90s Week Best of the Decade Video Podcasts TV All TV Reviews Interviews 2022 Fall TV Preview 2022 Emmys Best TV Shows of 2022, So Far Influencers: The Craft of TV 2022 Video Podcasts Awards All Awards 2023 Oscar Predictions TV Awards Calendar Film Awards Calendar Thompson on Hollywood Influencers: Profiles of a Partnership 2022 Awards Spotlight Spring 2022 Craft Considerations Top of the Line Animation Podcasts Video All Video Podcasts Consider This Conversations Toolkit Sundance Studio Awards Spotlight Winter 2022 Tune In Shop Gift Guides Tech Movies and TV to Buy and Stream More About Team How to Pitch Stories and Articles to IndieWire Advertise with IndieWire Confidential Tips News All News Galleries Lists Box Office Trailers Festivals Thompson on Hollywood Film All Film Reviews Interviews Profiles of a Partnership 2022 Best Movies of 2022, So Far 2022 Fall Movie Preview 2023 Oscars ’90s Week Best of the Decade Video Podcasts TV All TV Reviews Interviews 2022 Fall TV Preview 2022 Emmys Best TV Shows of 2022, So Far Influencers: The Craft of TV 2022 Video Podcasts Awards All Awards 2023 Oscar Predictions TV Awards Calendar Film Awards Calendar Thompson on Hollywood Influencers: Profiles of a Partnership 2022 Awards Spotlight Spring 2022 Craft Considerations Top of the Line Animation Podcasts Video All Video Podcasts Consider This Conversations Toolkit Sundance Studio Awards Spotlight Winter 2022 Tune In Shop Gift Guides Tech Movies and TV to Buy and Stream More About Team How to Pitch Stories and Articles to IndieWire Advertise with IndieWire Confidential Tips
Telluride Filmmaker Bryan Fogel attempts to pick up the pieces that his shattering Icarus left behind
Robert Daniels Sep 2, 2022 7:00 pm Share This Article Reddit LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Talk “Icarus: The Aftermath” You could, rightly, characterize director Bryan Fogel's Academy Award-winning documentary "Icarus" as the product of dumb luck. It began as one film - a "Super Size Me"-type concept whereby Fogel, a cycling enthusiast, attempted to expose the ease of illegal doping by injecting himself with steroids - that became an arresting investigation into Russia's decades-long use of performance-enhancing drugs, with the colorful Grigory Rodchenkov, head of the country's anti-doping laboratory, as the primary whistleblower. With Rodchenkov's testimony, Fogel made the pervasive rot of Russian sports into an enthralling piece of storytelling.
thumb_upLike (45)
commentReply (1)
shareShare
visibility630 views
thumb_up45 likes
comment
1 replies
L
Luna Park 4 minutes ago
And yet, despite its envelope-pushing search for the truth, "Icarus" ended as almost all documentari...
H
Harper Kim Member
access_time
6 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
And yet, despite its envelope-pushing search for the truth, "Icarus" ended as almost all documentaries do: The audience's eyes are opened and the subject who did the revealing fades into the background. Toward the end of the film, Rodchenkov's lawyer, Jim Walden, appears to explain that his client is now in hiding, dodging the Russian government's hit squads.
thumb_upLike (15)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up15 likes
comment
3 replies
M
Madison Singh 4 minutes ago
Related
'The Novelist's Film' Review: Hong Sang-soo Gets More Personal than ...
J
James Smith 4 minutes ago
But Fogel achieves the miraculous, because "Icarus: The Aftermath" isn't just a marked improvement o...
'The Novelist's Film' Review: Hong Sang-soo Gets More Personal than Ever in Tipsy Ode to Artistic Freedom Canada's Oscar Entry Is About Chinese Censorship, but It Ignores Another Kind of Propaganda
Related
Oscars 2023: Best Original Score Predictions Martin Scorsese's Favorite Movies: 50 Films the Director Wants You to See Even in a cinematic landscape proliferated by sequels, documentaries rarely return with a part two. And when they do - in films like "Fahrenheit 11/9," "Powaqqatsi," "Super Size Me 2: Holy Chicken!" - they struggle to match the splendor and wit of their predecessor. It's why no one would blame you if you walked into the follow-up to Fogel's "Icarus" with mocking disapproval.
thumb_upLike (32)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up32 likes
comment
3 replies
E
Emma Wilson 2 minutes ago
But Fogel achieves the miraculous, because "Icarus: The Aftermath" isn't just a marked improvement o...
K
Kevin Wang 4 minutes ago
We are also aware how the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) attempted to hold Vladimir Putin's governm...
But Fogel achieves the miraculous, because "Icarus: The Aftermath" isn't just a marked improvement over "Icarus." Instead, through following Rodchenkov's journey to attain asylum in America, "The Aftermath" reconfigures our understanding of investigative documentaries by disclosing the difficult plight whistleblowers must endure once the cameras depart. Fogel's sequel initially takes place in the immediate dust of "Icarus." With the assistance of a security team, and a lone cameraman following him, Rodchenkov moves from hotel to hotel, remote cabin to remote cabin, as he watches Russia deal with the consequences of their doping scandal whose ramifications turn out to be surprisingly light. Having lived the last five years, we know that in the following month and years after "Icarus," the International Olympic Committee (IOC) banned Russia from competing but not their athletes.
thumb_upLike (16)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up16 likes
comment
3 replies
H
Harper Kim 1 minutes ago
We are also aware how the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) attempted to hold Vladimir Putin's governm...
G
Grace Liu 3 minutes ago
That established knowledge can give "Aftermath" a repetitive quality, especially as Fogel tries to r...
We are also aware how the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) attempted to hold Vladimir Putin's government accountable for the decades-long, state-backed corruption of their own testing program. So, unlike "Icarus," there are few opportunities for Fogel to unearth shocking secrets.
thumb_upLike (20)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up20 likes
comment
3 replies
N
Noah Davis 3 minutes ago
That established knowledge can give "Aftermath" a repetitive quality, especially as Fogel tries to r...
J
Joseph Kim 7 minutes ago
In "Aftermath," these diaries prove to be, at least initially, a frustrating red herring. They force...
That established knowledge can give "Aftermath" a repetitive quality, especially as Fogel tries to recapture the enrapturing fact-finding glamour of his previous film. In "Aftermath," Rodchenkov's hidden diaries, which he left in Russia before he arrived in America in 2015, become a focal point of Fogel's desire for earth-shattering news. In "Icarus," Rodchenkov's meticulous journals - which outlined his daily routine, plus nefarious meetings and strategies in which he participated with his government's approval - proved indispensable in carving a case against Russia, so it makes sense for them to take center stage again here.
thumb_upLike (49)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up49 likes
S
Scarlett Brown Member
access_time
28 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
In "Aftermath," these diaries prove to be, at least initially, a frustrating red herring. They force us on a treadmill of watching a stoic Rodchenkov living in exile, combing through a barrage of clips where Putin tries to discredit the scientist to the world, and a stream of examples of Russia assassinating political enemies and purported traitors.
thumb_upLike (41)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up41 likes
comment
1 replies
I
Isabella Johnson 5 minutes ago
Lauren Brinkman and Wyatt Rogowski's editing takes on a frenetic pace, instilling the infiltration o...
H
Harper Kim Member
access_time
24 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
Lauren Brinkman and Wyatt Rogowski's editing takes on a frenetic pace, instilling the infiltration of Russia during the World Cup in 2018 to retrieve Rodchenkov's stashed diaries back to America with the verve of an espionage thriller. That kinetic pacing, and cinematographer Jake Swantko's visceral guerilla-style filmmaking, cannot keep up with the nothingburger these journals seem to be. Especially because Fogel, who featured himself so heavily in "Icarus,” is mostly unseen for half of "Aftermath." Similar to "Icarus," however, the diaries begin with one purpose, only to gain richer meaning and better usage later.
thumb_upLike (36)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up36 likes
W
William Brown Member
access_time
27 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
Rodchenkov hasn't seen his wife Veronika and children since 2015, and their separation especially lays a heavy burden on Veronika, who's more than a little angry that her family is now torn apart. And while Rodchenkov believes the light at the end of the tunnel is near, his wife's hope has evaporated like a puddle in July.
thumb_upLike (7)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up7 likes
comment
2 replies
I
Isabella Johnson 25 minutes ago
In the process, the once-stoic Rodchenkov becomes more isolated, slowly losing his identity in the p...
A
Audrey Mueller 16 minutes ago
It's why when Fogel emerges in the film's second half, both the film and Rodchenkov develop renewed ...
T
Thomas Anderson Member
access_time
50 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
In the process, the once-stoic Rodchenkov becomes more isolated, slowly losing his identity in the physical sense - dyeing his curls and altering his facial hair - and in the personal realm as well, as he watches news reports of his former friends' and colleagues' assassinations. The journals eventually become more than evidence against the state. They are the records of his existence in a protective life of subterfuge designed to erase his presence.
thumb_upLike (4)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up4 likes
A
Amelia Singh Moderator
access_time
55 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
It's why when Fogel emerges in the film's second half, both the film and Rodchenkov develop renewed energy. "Aftermath" rediscovers the magic that the two men's friendship provided in "Icarus." "You changed my life," Rodchenkov fondly tells Fogel. They share laughs, trade playful barbs (Rodchenkov makes fun of Fogel's age spots), and share their respective triumphs.
thumb_upLike (27)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up27 likes
comment
3 replies
M
Mason Rodriguez 26 minutes ago
No one else is capable of getting the captivating Rodchenkov to open up quite like this director can...
D
Dylan Patel 39 minutes ago
In pulling out these difficulties, "Aftermath" doesn't feel like dumb luck. It's smart and controlle...
No one else is capable of getting the captivating Rodchenkov to open up quite like this director can - you can see the soft touch that Fogel gained by talking with an activist fighting against a murderous state in his documentary "The Dissident" - and it's how we can easily see the wounds the last few years have left on this scientist, even while he tries to hide such clear heartache. And while Fogel dutifully employs the rest of the documentary to update us on the new players to emerge in the fight against performance-enhancing drugs, such as the unbreakable and honest Yuri Ganus (the outspoken head of the Russian anti-doping agency) - "Aftermath"thrums by turning its gaze toward the ordeals faced by whistleblowers like Ganus and Rodchenkov.
thumb_upLike (38)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up38 likes
comment
3 replies
H
Hannah Kim 3 minutes ago
In pulling out these difficulties, "Aftermath" doesn't feel like dumb luck. It's smart and controlle...
E
Ethan Thomas 9 minutes ago
By the end, the courageous Rodchenkov gains little else except thankless solitude and fragments of h...
In pulling out these difficulties, "Aftermath" doesn't feel like dumb luck. It's smart and controlled storytelling. "What did you gain?" asks an exasperated Veronika of her husband.
thumb_upLike (22)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up22 likes
comment
3 replies
O
Oliver Taylor 13 minutes ago
By the end, the courageous Rodchenkov gains little else except thankless solitude and fragments of h...
Z
Zoe Mueller 11 minutes ago
Grade B
“Icarus: The Aftermath” premiered at the 2022 Telluride Film Festival...
By the end, the courageous Rodchenkov gains little else except thankless solitude and fragments of hope. It's incredible that he doesn't seem to carry any regrets. Though we may come to wonder whether Fogel feels remorse about the role he played in putting his friend in this predicament - it's a question the filmmaker never asks of himself - even in the difficult-to-swallow forlornness of its conclusion, "Icarus: The Aftermath" is a poignant and powerful document about the unpredictable burdens of heroism.
thumb_upLike (18)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up18 likes
I
Isaac Schmidt Member
access_time
30 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
Grade B
“Icarus: The Aftermath” premiered at the 2022 Telluride Film Festival. It is currently seeking U.S. distribution. Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news!
thumb_upLike (3)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up3 likes
comment
1 replies
A
Aria Nguyen 2 minutes ago
Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. This Article is related to: Film, Reviews and tagged Bryan F...
L
Luna Park Member
access_time
48 minutes ago
Thursday, 01 May 2025
Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. This Article is related to: Film, Reviews and tagged Bryan Fogel, Icarus, Icarus: The Aftermath, Reviews, Telluride Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox Subscribe
Podcasts
Listen to these IndieWire podcasts.
thumb_upLike (14)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up14 likes
comment
3 replies
I
Isaac Schmidt 32 minutes ago
Oscar Season Is a Battle Between Mainstream and Arthouse Movies
Oscar Season Is a Battle Between Mainstream and Arthouse Movies
Paul Schrader Survives Hospital Scare and Says ‘ I Will Direct Again’
The Film Industry Continues to Diversify but It s Never Enough — NYFF Director Explains All
Craft
Interviews with leading film and TV creators about their process and craft.
Oscars 2023 How Will Last Year’ s Rule Change Impact This Year’ s Score Race
Created in Chaos The Cinematography of ‘ Blonde’
How the ‘ Rings of Power’ VFX Teams Created the Epic Flood and Mount Doom Eruption in Episode 6
Featured Posts
The 100 Best Movies of the ’90s The 100 Best Movies of the Decade 60 Must-See New Movies to Watch This Fall Season Fall TV Preview: The 20 Shows You’ll Want to Watch ‘White Lotus’ Season 2 Sets Premiere Date: All the Details for the Series’ Italy-Bound Return ad