igforum.bio
/
batman-s-dead-in-gotham-knights-but-are-you-really-playing-as-batman-in-arkham-asylum
-
236631
J
%Begin Batman's dead in Gotham Knights, but are you really playing as Batman in Arkham Asylum? Eurogamer.net If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.
visibility
886 views
thumb_up
8 likes
E
Batman's dead in Gotham Knights, but are you really playing as Batman in Arkham Asylum? To Dead Man's Point.
thumb_up
9 likes
G
Feature by Christian Donlan Features Editor Published on 7 Oct 2022 49 comments I don't know if you've read much about the new Batman game, Gotham Knights. I'll call it a Batman game for simplicity's sake. The truth is - as far as we've been told - this is actually a Batman game in which you don't play as Batman.
thumb_up
17 likes
A
Batman's dead, so instead you play as four members of the wider Bat family. In fact, this is probably what you've been reading about if you have been reading about the game. This is all super interesting, I think.
thumb_up
29 likes
L
Gotham Knights is already a Batman game not made by Rocksteady, and now it doesn't have the main character either - as far as we've been told. I'm intrigued to see the results, but the whole discussion has also made me think about the first Batman game in this series, Arkham Asylum, and how you definitely play as Batman in that - except when it comes to my very favourite moment in the game, which is also the point at which the relationship between player and onscreen avatar becomes a little more complicated. Firstly, yes, a lot of games complicate this relationship.
thumb_up
20 likes
E
You control the characters in GTA, for example, but when you're driving to a mission they're talking, and they're saying stuff that is probably a surprise to you, the player, so there's that gap there to ponder. You are the people on the screen, and you must be, because you tell them when to duck, when to reload. But they have a sliver of life that you will never quite get control of, because if you did, the game's narrative wouldn't work.
thumb_up
6 likes
K
Watch on YouTube Zoe went hands-on with Gotham Knights. Back to Batman. Batman talks to Oracle and what have you, but that's fine for the most part, because you're the one sneaking him through vents and deciding in which order to take down goons.
thumb_up
22 likes
V
But then at a certain point in the game, Batman encounters Bane, and after defeating Bane, he's disturbed about something. Like the bit-part doctor in a million soap operas, he decides he has to do more tests. He needs to get to the Batcave.
thumb_up
14 likes
E
But he's trapped on Arkham, isn't he? This is it: my favourite moment in Arkham Asylum - in any of the Batman games, in fact. You go to Dead Man's Point in North Arkham, a lovely bit of theatre that takes you away from the main stomping grounds of the narrative, and also gives you a melancholic view of Gotham itself, separated by water.
thumb_up
46 likes
J
You dive - or rather Batman dives, because we're in cutscene territory - from a cliff edge and then, swish, you're being scanned by lasers, and a wall of rock reveals a secret door. You walk through, into a corridor with electric lighting, through a shimmering wall of water - another lovely moment - and wow. You're here.
thumb_up
8 likes
S
A second Batcave on Arkham Island. There are a lot of reasons why this works.
thumb_up
5 likes
H
The theatrical staging of the reveal. The growing awareness that Rocksteady is so comfortable with Batman's world that it's willing to create its own elements.
thumb_up
33 likes
L
The sheer star power of actually being in such a hallowed place. All fine.
thumb_up
9 likes
M
But the real reason it works is much more complicated, I think. The Batcave reveal works because Batman knows something that you don't: that he has a cave on this island in the first place. He knows something you don't know.
thumb_up
4 likes
V
Which is weird, because aren't you Batman in the first place? Isn't that the premise of the whole game?
thumb_up
47 likes
E
Here's the Batcave in Arkham Asylum. Years ago I was taught about this concept: dramatic irony. Dramatic irony, I was told, is one of the most complex tools a writer can deploy.
thumb_up
45 likes
A
Dramatic irony occurs when the people in the audience know more than the people on screen. To use a simple Hitchcock example: two people are talking at a table, but only the audience knows there's a bomb underneath the table and it's counting down to the explosion. Dramatic irony!
thumb_up
33 likes
L
At table level it's all chats about holidays and what the weather's like. Below the table, though, we, the audience, are screaming: get away! Stop talking!
thumb_up
22 likes
L
Okay. Dramatic irony rarely needs a bomb in order to work. And it's rarely used only to create suspense.
thumb_up
45 likes
S
Maybe one character has had an affair, and we know about it but their partner doesn't. Maybe the kid's come home from school and we know what they got in that test but the parents don't. Maybe we know they earned Class President, or got expelled!
thumb_up
21 likes
E
The Batcave sequence works because of a sort of reversed dramatic irony. Batman knows something and he hasn't shared it with us.
thumb_up
40 likes
T
All this time he's known there's a Batcave on the island. But we didn't need to know until now, even though we are him.
thumb_up
5 likes
B
Sort of. So he has this internal life that we are not privy to. There is a him without us.
thumb_up
13 likes
N
Turns out there was a Batcave in PlayStation Home. You get this in a lot of movies too - caper movies are particularly rich in it.
thumb_up
3 likes
R
The audience think Danny Ocean's con failed, but only because Danny didn't let us into the true nature of the con in the first place. We followed him right until he got into the Bellagio's vault, and then he pushed us aside a bit and worked a solitary magic without us. But you know where I'm going with this: that's fine, but we never really thought we were Danny Ocean up until that point.
thumb_up
1 likes
M
The film is exploiting a separation of protagonist and audience that everyone understands from the start. Arkham Asylum is a bit different. Games are a bit different And I'm tempted to say that Batman is a bit different in general.
thumb_up
12 likes
C
We're not just playing a character in these games, we're playing a character who is already storied, already deeply famous, already slopping around in lore. Arkham Asylum's greatness, then, is that it doesn't always allow us to be Batman - sometimes we get to be near Batman while he does something cool that surprises us. Maybe Gotham Knights is drawing from a deeper well after all.
thumb_up
47 likes
R
To see this content please enable targeting cookies. Manage cookie settings Become a Eurogamer subscriber and get your first month for £1 Get your first month for £1 (normally £3.99) when you buy a Standard Eurogamer subscription. Enjoy ad-free browsing, merch discounts, our monthly letter from the editor, and show your support with a supporter-exclusive comment flair!
thumb_up
11 likes
A
Support us View supporter archive
More Features Feature What games get wrong about horses And what they could do about it. 27 Feature Shout out to all the Overwatch supports - where would we be without you? Merci.
thumb_up
7 likes
N
55 Feature From abandoned board game to birthing a genre: Football Manager at 40 Kick off. 21 Feature How I became an Elden Ring detective It started with a save game... 26
Latest Articles Atari will hold RollerCoaster Tycoon rights for another decade Ups and downs.
thumb_up
6 likes
G
7 Jelly Deals Logitech's G Pro X gaming headset is its lowest-ever price during Amazon's Early Access sale Prime Members can get it for just £52. Jelly Deals Save over £500 off the retail price on this beefy ASUS TUF Dash gaming laptop from Amazon Under £1080 for an RTX 3070 laptop.
thumb_up
30 likes
I
Lady Dimitrescu will be a tad smaller in Resident Evil Village's Mercenaries DLC Level the playing field. 1
Supporters Only Premium only Off Topic: Take a minute to appreciate Cookin' with Coolio's incredible scallops recipe.
thumb_up
40 likes
D
What a great book. Premium only Off Topic: Reading City of Glass in comic form "Where exactly am I going?" Premium only Off Topic: Il Buco is a transporting film about a really big hole Underlands.
thumb_up
33 likes
A
Off-Topic Netflix handled Sandman brilliantly It was Dreamy. 9 Buy things with globes on them And other lovely Eurogamer merch in our official store!
thumb_up
26 likes
K
Explore our store
thumb_up
29 likes
Similar Discussions
-
You couldn t speak your mind I felt suffocated Simi Singh on why he left India for Ireland
-
IND vs AUS 2022 Dinesh Karthik s funny dig at Daniel Sams
-
Who is The Sea Snake in New Game of Thrones Spinoff? What We Know
-
My Trip APK Download for Android
-
SPORTWELL APK Download for Android
-
Stick War Legacy APK Download for Android
-
Airveda Air Quality APK Download for Android
-
Tebak Gambar Seru APK Download for Android
-
Meurtre de Lola ce que les parents de la coll gienne ont dit au maire de Fouquereuil
-
Shaq roasts Logan Paul for wearing Jeffrey Dahmer glasses Dexerto
-
FIFA 23 How to Do Manual Headers The Nerd Stash
-
Horniman Museum To Return 72 Benin Artifacts To Nigeria Brings Forth A Discussion On Object Repatriation
-
The iPhone 14 gets a stunning transparent back with this mod Digital Trends
-
Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations
-
Apple Lightning to USB Cable 6 Foot Reliable Flexible iPhone Charging
-
Excel SIGN Function Tutorial
-
Compare Chevrolet HHR vs Chrysler PT Cruiser CarBuzz
-
Noah Baumbach Wants to Make a Musical IndieWire
-
Recetas sin cocción Mayo Clinic
-
10 Essential Facts About Your Gallbladder Everyday Health
-
Vevor Led Sign Software
-
Charcot foot Symptoms causes treatment and more
-
A Patient s Guide to Hypertension Cedars Sinai
-
Who is Guren in Naruto
-
NBA 2K23 exclusive PlayStation MyTeam challenges revealed Here is what we know
-
I ve got a bad feeling about the guy Manchester United legend sets off on astonishing rant on potential transfer target
-
Thanh Le demonstrates variations of hugging in martial arts
-
Potential spoiler of a return tonight on WWE RAW
-
Gamescom 2022 The latest Jackbox is bringing much needed changes to the game
-
There s a huge Prime Day discount on SanDisk s 512GB micro SD card