igforum.bio / stock-image-sites-face-bias-accusations - 114028
J
%Start Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Search Close GO News &gt; Software & Apps <h1> Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations</h1> <h2> Stereotypes abound</h2> By Sascha Brodsky Sascha Brodsky Senior Tech Reporter Macalester College Columbia University Sascha Brodsky is a freelance journalist based in New York City. His writing has appeared in The Atlantic, the Guardian, the Los Angeles Times and many other publications.
Julia Zhang Member
access_time 1 minutes ago
%Start Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Search Close GO News > Software & Apps

Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations

Stereotypes abound

By Sascha Brodsky Sascha Brodsky Senior Tech Reporter Macalester College Columbia University Sascha Brodsky is a freelance journalist based in New York City. His writing has appeared in The Atlantic, the Guardian, the Los Angeles Times and many other publications.
thumb_up Like (24)
comment Reply (2)
share Share
visibility 832 views
thumb_up 24 likes
comment 2 replies
V
Victoria Lopez 1 minutes ago
lifewire's editorial guidelines Published on November 2, 2020 09:54AM EST Tweet Share Email Tweet Sh...
S
Scarlett Brown 1 minutes ago
Stock image sites have been accused of under-representing minorities and marginalized groups. The ph...
J
lifewire's editorial guidelines Published on November 2, 2020 09:54AM EST Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Software & Apps Mobile Phones Internet & Security Computers & Tablets Smart Life Home Theater & Entertainment Software & Apps Social Media Streaming Gaming <h3> Key Takeaways</h3> Online stock images can show racist stereotypes of minorities, observers say.A Lifewire review of stock images found caricatures of Jews. Last year, Pete Buttigieg&#39;s presidential campaign was criticized over its use of a stock image of a Kenyan woman on a campaign webpage. Nora Carol Photography Some online stock images depicting women and minorities are coming under increasing scrutiny from critics who say they can perpetuate racist and misogynistic stereotypes.
Joseph Kim Member
access_time 2 minutes ago
lifewire's editorial guidelines Published on November 2, 2020 09:54AM EST Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Software & Apps Mobile Phones Internet & Security Computers & Tablets Smart Life Home Theater & Entertainment Software & Apps Social Media Streaming Gaming

Key Takeaways

Online stock images can show racist stereotypes of minorities, observers say.A Lifewire review of stock images found caricatures of Jews. Last year, Pete Buttigieg's presidential campaign was criticized over its use of a stock image of a Kenyan woman on a campaign webpage. Nora Carol Photography Some online stock images depicting women and minorities are coming under increasing scrutiny from critics who say they can perpetuate racist and misogynistic stereotypes.
thumb_up Like (13)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 13 likes
comment 1 replies
S
Sofia Garcia 2 minutes ago
Stock image sites have been accused of under-representing minorities and marginalized groups. The ph...
L
Stock image sites have been accused of under-representing minorities and marginalized groups. The photos that have been downloaded from these sites have gotten some politicians into trouble for using the wrong ethnicity in campaigns.
Liam Wilson Member
access_time 12 minutes ago
Stock image sites have been accused of under-representing minorities and marginalized groups. The photos that have been downloaded from these sites have gotten some politicians into trouble for using the wrong ethnicity in campaigns.
thumb_up Like (15)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 15 likes
comment 3 replies
A
Andrew Wilson 7 minutes ago
And in some isolated instances, the images appear to demean the people they mean to represent. "Ther...
O
Oliver Taylor 11 minutes ago
There are very few women of color who show up, and almost never images of women with any visible dis...
Show 1 more replies
R
And in some isolated instances, the images appear to demean the people they mean to represent. "There is implicit bias in stock imagery, mostly due to the way the images are tagged and categorized," Minal Bopaiah, Founder &amp; Principal Consultant of Brevity &amp; Wit, a design firm that focuses on diversity, said in an email interview. "For example, if you search for 'attractive woman,' most stock image databases return results that are predominantly White and of the same body size and shape.
Ryan Garcia Member
access_time 20 minutes ago
And in some isolated instances, the images appear to demean the people they mean to represent. "There is implicit bias in stock imagery, mostly due to the way the images are tagged and categorized," Minal Bopaiah, Founder & Principal Consultant of Brevity & Wit, a design firm that focuses on diversity, said in an email interview. "For example, if you search for 'attractive woman,' most stock image databases return results that are predominantly White and of the same body size and shape.
thumb_up Like (47)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 47 likes
comment 1 replies
J
James Smith 10 minutes ago
There are very few women of color who show up, and almost never images of women with any visible dis...
S
There are very few women of color who show up, and almost never images of women with any visible disabilities." <h2> Anti-Semitic Images </h2> A quick search of stock images sites found illustrations that seem biased. A review of Getty Images by Lifewire found some pictures that appear to reinforce anti-Semitic stereotypes.
Sophie Martin Member
access_time 25 minutes ago
There are very few women of color who show up, and almost never images of women with any visible disabilities."

Anti-Semitic Images

A quick search of stock images sites found illustrations that seem biased. A review of Getty Images by Lifewire found some pictures that appear to reinforce anti-Semitic stereotypes.
thumb_up Like (4)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 4 likes
comment 1 replies
I
Isaac Schmidt 12 minutes ago
For example, one image shows a long-nosed man with devil wings holding a coin. The illustration is l...
M
For example, one image shows a long-nosed man with devil wings holding a coin. The illustration is labeled &#34;Making a deal with the devil, horned red demon flying and showing a Bitcoin Cryptocurrency to a man.&#34; Lifewire asked the Anti Defamation League (ADL), an anti-bias organization, to review these images.
Mason Rodriguez Member
access_time 12 minutes ago
For example, one image shows a long-nosed man with devil wings holding a coin. The illustration is labeled "Making a deal with the devil, horned red demon flying and showing a Bitcoin Cryptocurrency to a man." Lifewire asked the Anti Defamation League (ADL), an anti-bias organization, to review these images.
thumb_up Like (25)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 25 likes
I
&#34;The character depicted in this image, with his stereotypically large nose, dark clothing, and desire for money, may raise anti-Semitic tropes in viewers, an ADL spokesperson said in an email interview. &#34;There are over a dozen other images in this series in which this character is in situations that evoke similar anti-Jewish stereotypes.
Isaac Schmidt Member
access_time 7 minutes ago
"The character depicted in this image, with his stereotypically large nose, dark clothing, and desire for money, may raise anti-Semitic tropes in viewers, an ADL spokesperson said in an email interview. "There are over a dozen other images in this series in which this character is in situations that evoke similar anti-Jewish stereotypes.
thumb_up Like (30)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 30 likes
comment 3 replies
E
Elijah Patel 2 minutes ago
We do not know whether the artist intended to include these anti-Semitic implications or whether thi...
L
Liam Wilson 6 minutes ago
Initial searches on Shutterstock and VectorStock found similarly limited results, with some images t...
Show 1 more replies
D
We do not know whether the artist intended to include these anti-Semitic implications or whether this is merely an unfortunate coincidence.&#34; alashi / Getty Images A search of various terms for Jews and Judaism on Getty Images &#34;returns some results which may give pause, including images of devils,&#34; the ADL spokesperson added. &#34;However, these images are also often tagged with labels such as &#34;Christianity&#34; and &#34;Religion,&#34; which suggests that they do not appear to be specifically targeting Jews, but rather western religions in general.
Daniel Kumar Member
access_time 16 minutes ago
We do not know whether the artist intended to include these anti-Semitic implications or whether this is merely an unfortunate coincidence." alashi / Getty Images A search of various terms for Jews and Judaism on Getty Images "returns some results which may give pause, including images of devils," the ADL spokesperson added. "However, these images are also often tagged with labels such as "Christianity" and "Religion," which suggests that they do not appear to be specifically targeting Jews, but rather western religions in general.
thumb_up Like (0)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 0 likes
comment 3 replies
J
Julia Zhang 8 minutes ago
Initial searches on Shutterstock and VectorStock found similarly limited results, with some images t...
D
Daniel Kumar 14 minutes ago
Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., tweeted that the use of the Kenyan image was "not ok or necessary."  ...
Show 1 more replies
N
Initial searches on Shutterstock and VectorStock found similarly limited results, with some images that may elicit anti-Semitic stereotypes even if not overtly anti-Semitic.&#34; The ADL spokesperson said the organization did not have any information that the issue of anti-Semitic images on stock photo sites is widespread, but added, &#34;we are aware that various stock websites have at times included offensive images, some of which include anti-Semitic stereotypes, in their inventories.&#34; Anne Flanagan, Senior Director and Head of External Communications for Getty Images said in an email interview that the company is &#34;reviewing the content to make sure the images depicted are compliant&#34; with existing content policies. She added that &#34;Getty Images regularly reviews content to ensure that it is compliant with not only legal, but also its societal responsibilities, and we have strict policies and standards in place to govern our contributors in the submission of content and our content inspectors in the review and approval of content submitted for inclusion on the site.&#34; <h2> Stock Politics </h2> Issues involving politics and stock images have emerged around the growing racial tension in American politics. Last year,&nbsp;Pete Buttigieg's presidential campaign was criticized over its use of a stock image of a Kenyan woman on a campaign web page promoting his plan to address racial inequality.&nbsp;Rep.
Nathan Chen Member
access_time 9 minutes ago
Initial searches on Shutterstock and VectorStock found similarly limited results, with some images that may elicit anti-Semitic stereotypes even if not overtly anti-Semitic." The ADL spokesperson said the organization did not have any information that the issue of anti-Semitic images on stock photo sites is widespread, but added, "we are aware that various stock websites have at times included offensive images, some of which include anti-Semitic stereotypes, in their inventories." Anne Flanagan, Senior Director and Head of External Communications for Getty Images said in an email interview that the company is "reviewing the content to make sure the images depicted are compliant" with existing content policies. She added that "Getty Images regularly reviews content to ensure that it is compliant with not only legal, but also its societal responsibilities, and we have strict policies and standards in place to govern our contributors in the submission of content and our content inspectors in the review and approval of content submitted for inclusion on the site."

Stock Politics

Issues involving politics and stock images have emerged around the growing racial tension in American politics. Last year, Pete Buttigieg's presidential campaign was criticized over its use of a stock image of a Kenyan woman on a campaign web page promoting his plan to address racial inequality. Rep.
thumb_up Like (32)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 32 likes
comment 2 replies
G
Grace Liu 8 minutes ago
Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., tweeted that the use of the Kenyan image was "not ok or necessary."  ...
I
Isaac Schmidt 8 minutes ago
It was part of a public apology for saying that he will "never agree with anybody disrespecting...
A
Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., tweeted that the use of the Kenyan image was "not ok or necessary."&nbsp;&nbsp; Companies and some public figures have been criticized for using stock images surrounding the recent Black Lives Matter protests. For example, New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees was criticized for using a six-year-old 'handshake against racism' stock image.
Amelia Singh Moderator
access_time 30 minutes ago
Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., tweeted that the use of the Kenyan image was "not ok or necessary."   Companies and some public figures have been criticized for using stock images surrounding the recent Black Lives Matter protests. For example, New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees was criticized for using a six-year-old 'handshake against racism' stock image.
thumb_up Like (9)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 9 likes
C
It was part of a&nbsp;public apology for saying that he will "never agree with anybody disrespecting the flag of the United States of America."&nbsp; The bias issue in stock images is common to many large data sets, experts say. "Photographers upload images that can unconsciously reinforce social stereotypes," Mikaela Pisani, AI company Rootstrap's Chief Data Scientist and Head of the company’s Machine Learning Practice Area, said in an email interview. "As users choose the same photos over and over again, the recommendation algorithms are skewed towards a social bias by surfacing 'popular' images." timsa / Getty Images Default searches may contain implicit bias, experts say.
Charlotte Lee Member
access_time 11 minutes ago
It was part of a public apology for saying that he will "never agree with anybody disrespecting the flag of the United States of America."  The bias issue in stock images is common to many large data sets, experts say. "Photographers upload images that can unconsciously reinforce social stereotypes," Mikaela Pisani, AI company Rootstrap's Chief Data Scientist and Head of the company’s Machine Learning Practice Area, said in an email interview. "As users choose the same photos over and over again, the recommendation algorithms are skewed towards a social bias by surfacing 'popular' images." timsa / Getty Images Default searches may contain implicit bias, experts say.
thumb_up Like (47)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 47 likes
comment 1 replies
A
Aria Nguyen 8 minutes ago
"A search for 'man' or 'woman' on iStock, for example, has a noticeable lack of ...
W
&#34;A search for &#39;man&#39; or &#39;woman&#39; on iStock, for example, has a noticeable lack of Asian and South Asian people,&#34; Pisani said. &#34;Beyond racial stereotypes, other biases such as age should also be considered and their impacts on society as conveyed through the use of stock photography.
William Brown Member
access_time 24 minutes ago
"A search for 'man' or 'woman' on iStock, for example, has a noticeable lack of Asian and South Asian people," Pisani said. "Beyond racial stereotypes, other biases such as age should also be considered and their impacts on society as conveyed through the use of stock photography.
thumb_up Like (5)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 5 likes
comment 3 replies
S
Sofia Garcia 9 minutes ago
"The racism is not overt—there are still options, the question is how many options. When searc...
C
Chloe Santos 17 minutes ago
There is a dearth of images of people of color with disabilities, which means the needs of people of...
Show 1 more replies
I
&#34;The racism is not overt—there are still options, the question is how many options. When searching for &#39;business people&#39; on Shutterstock, 15million results surfaced. When filters of &#39;Caucasian woman&#39; and &#39;Black woman&#39; are applied—the discrepancy is almost a 1.9million results vs just 25,000.&#34; Racism can also be subtle in some stock images, observers say. Bopaiah cites the example of &#34;centering White people in a &#39;multicultural&#39; image and putting people of color on the margins of the frame, and in failing to incorporate people of color in issues that concern other marginalized groups.
Isaac Schmidt Member
access_time 65 minutes ago
"The racism is not overt—there are still options, the question is how many options. When searching for 'business people' on Shutterstock, 15million results surfaced. When filters of 'Caucasian woman' and 'Black woman' are applied—the discrepancy is almost a 1.9million results vs just 25,000." Racism can also be subtle in some stock images, observers say. Bopaiah cites the example of "centering White people in a 'multicultural' image and putting people of color on the margins of the frame, and in failing to incorporate people of color in issues that concern other marginalized groups.
thumb_up Like (40)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 40 likes
comment 2 replies
E
Ethan Thomas 26 minutes ago
There is a dearth of images of people of color with disabilities, which means the needs of people of...
D
Dylan Patel 6 minutes ago
For example, Getty's #ShowUs collection of images of purposefully diverse women, that don't conform ...
L
There is a dearth of images of people of color with disabilities, which means the needs of people of color with disabilities are often ignored or erased.&#34; <h2> Dealing With the Issue </h2> Education is key to combating the problem, experts say. &#34;Stock image companies should educate their staff editors so that they are better equipped to identify and flag racist and anti-Semitic stereotypes and images,&#34; the ADL spokesperson said. &#34;Implicit bias and other anti-bias training for their staffs could help prevent potentially offensive images from making it into their catalogs.&#34; Stock photography sites have attempted to tackle bias issues by encouraging diversity.
Liam Wilson Member
access_time 14 minutes ago
There is a dearth of images of people of color with disabilities, which means the needs of people of color with disabilities are often ignored or erased."

Dealing With the Issue

Education is key to combating the problem, experts say. "Stock image companies should educate their staff editors so that they are better equipped to identify and flag racist and anti-Semitic stereotypes and images," the ADL spokesperson said. "Implicit bias and other anti-bias training for their staffs could help prevent potentially offensive images from making it into their catalogs." Stock photography sites have attempted to tackle bias issues by encouraging diversity.
thumb_up Like (40)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 40 likes
comment 2 replies
Z
Zoe Mueller 3 minutes ago
For example, Getty's #ShowUs collection of images of purposefully diverse women, that don't conform ...
A
Ava White 5 minutes ago
"From a strategic communications perspective, company officials in charge of messaging need to a...
S
For example, Getty's #ShowUs collection of images of purposefully diverse women, that don't conform to the 'Instagram-standard' of women's bodies. "It's a step in the right direction, ensuring that users have to take fewer steps to access a wide variety of images that aren't conforming to stereotypes," Pisani said.&nbsp; Companies should avoid using stock photo images that exacerbate racial tensions such as those that show police brutality, Wendy Melillo, an Associate Professor of Journalism in the School of Communication at American University, said in an email interview.
Sebastian Silva Member
access_time 15 minutes ago
For example, Getty's #ShowUs collection of images of purposefully diverse women, that don't conform to the 'Instagram-standard' of women's bodies. "It's a step in the right direction, ensuring that users have to take fewer steps to access a wide variety of images that aren't conforming to stereotypes," Pisani said.  Companies should avoid using stock photo images that exacerbate racial tensions such as those that show police brutality, Wendy Melillo, an Associate Professor of Journalism in the School of Communication at American University, said in an email interview.
thumb_up Like (32)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 32 likes
L
&#34;From a strategic communications perspective, company officials in charge of messaging need to ask themselves &#39;why am I choosing this stock photo image and what am I trying to say?&#39;,&#34; Melillo said. &#34;If these officials are using the photo as a way to project some image that their company stands in solidarity against racism, they would be better off keeping their mouth shut.
Liam Wilson Member
access_time 32 minutes ago
"From a strategic communications perspective, company officials in charge of messaging need to ask themselves 'why am I choosing this stock photo image and what am I trying to say?'," Melillo said. "If these officials are using the photo as a way to project some image that their company stands in solidarity against racism, they would be better off keeping their mouth shut.
thumb_up Like (2)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 2 likes
comment 3 replies
H
Henry Schmidt 28 minutes ago
Such a strategy is not authentic and will only invite criticism rather than respect." In this fr...
N
Noah Davis 10 minutes ago
Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subs...
Show 1 more replies
J
Such a strategy is not authentic and will only invite criticism rather than respect.&#34; In this fraught election year, the US appears more divided than ever. Stock images may be a small but ever present part of the problem as they reinforce stereotypes and biases.
Julia Zhang Member
access_time 34 minutes ago
Such a strategy is not authentic and will only invite criticism rather than respect." In this fraught election year, the US appears more divided than ever. Stock images may be a small but ever present part of the problem as they reinforce stereotypes and biases.
thumb_up Like (2)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 2 likes
comment 2 replies
N
Nathan Chen 23 minutes ago
Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subs...
D
David Cohen 12 minutes ago
Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire Our Commitment to Diversity & ...
M
Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subscribe Tell us why!
Madison Singh Member
access_time 54 minutes ago
Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subscribe Tell us why!
thumb_up Like (13)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 13 likes
comment 2 replies
A
Audrey Mueller 47 minutes ago
Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire Our Commitment to Diversity & ...
A
Ava White 43 minutes ago
What Is Google Images and How Does It Work? The 7 Best Apps to Write on Pictures How to Change the W...
Z
Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire Our Commitment to Diversity & Inclusion Lifewire How-To Editorial Guidelines 9 Best Sites for Public Domain Images 8 Best Sites for Watching Free Horror Movies 8 Best Free Photo Editing Apps How to Customize a New Tab Page in Chrome The Best Image Search Engines on the Web How to Stop Political Texts How to Turn a Photo into a Nagel-Inspired Vector Portrait How to Not Get Banned From the Xbox Network Kickstarter vs. Indiegogo. Which Is Better?
Zoe Mueller Member
access_time 19 minutes ago
Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire Our Commitment to Diversity & Inclusion Lifewire How-To Editorial Guidelines 9 Best Sites for Public Domain Images 8 Best Sites for Watching Free Horror Movies 8 Best Free Photo Editing Apps How to Customize a New Tab Page in Chrome The Best Image Search Engines on the Web How to Stop Political Texts How to Turn a Photo into a Nagel-Inspired Vector Portrait How to Not Get Banned From the Xbox Network Kickstarter vs. Indiegogo. Which Is Better?
thumb_up Like (40)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 40 likes
comment 2 replies
O
Oliver Taylor 17 minutes ago
What Is Google Images and How Does It Work? The 7 Best Apps to Write on Pictures How to Change the W...
J
Jack Thompson 11 minutes ago
Experts Say Color E Ink Might Be a Fad Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up News...
J
What Is Google Images and How Does It Work? The 7 Best Apps to Write on Pictures How to Change the Wallpaper on your iPhone What Is a Property Release and When Do You Need One?
Julia Zhang Member
access_time 100 minutes ago
What Is Google Images and How Does It Work? The 7 Best Apps to Write on Pictures How to Change the Wallpaper on your iPhone What Is a Property Release and When Do You Need One?
thumb_up Like (11)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 11 likes
comment 2 replies
S
Scarlett Brown 56 minutes ago
Experts Say Color E Ink Might Be a Fad Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up News...
M
Madison Singh 12 minutes ago
Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Searc...
B
Experts Say Color E Ink Might Be a Fad Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies
Brandon Kumar Member
access_time 21 minutes ago
Experts Say Color E Ink Might Be a Fad Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies
thumb_up Like (14)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 14 likes
comment 1 replies
L
Lucas Martinez 20 minutes ago
Stock Image Sites Face Bias Accusations GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Searc...

Write a Reply

Similar Discussions