C
%Begin The Whale review: Brendan Fraser can’t save this limp drama Digital Trends Skip to main content Trending: Wordle Today October 24 Dell XPS 15 vs. Razer Blade 15 Best Dolby Atmos Soundbars iPhone 14 Plus Review Halo Rise vs. Nest Hub 2nd Gen HP Envy x360 13 (2022) Review Best Chromebook Printers Home Movies & TVReviews
visibility
577 views
thumb_up
17 likes
J
Dowd September 12, 2022 Share In Darren Aronofsky’s The Whale, mounds upon mounds of prosthetics transform Brendan Fraser into a character many times his real size. That’s the hook of the movie, and its headline, and also its early controversy. Why, some have wondered, have such great resources been expended to allow an actor of Fraser’s average stature to play a role a naturally larger man could have occupied instead?
thumb_up
50 likes
I
Are so-called fat suits inherently dehumanizing, or have they just been put to that use in the past? Wherever one lands on such questions, the reality is that the elaborate full-body makeover of The Whale is no less real than anything else in this fatally overwrought melodrama of compulsion and atonement. Its dramatic heft is entirely phony, too.
thumb_up
35 likes
C
Fraser plays Charlie, a college English professor who teaches remotely from his home in small-town Idaho. Charlie keeps his webcam off, telling his students it’s a technical error.
thumb_up
12 likes
W
In reality, he just doesn’t want them to see him, and discover the truth: that he’s a shut-in who weighs over 600 pounds. It’s been years since Charlie’s made any attempt to lose weight, and a new blood pressure reading puts him in the “call 911 immediately” danger zone.
thumb_up
11 likes
M
His overeating is killing him, rapidly and decisively. But he won’t go to the hospital.
thumb_up
48 likes
L
The Whale offers therapy-couch explanations for what Charlie has slowly been doing to his body over the years. (He was always bigger, he explains, but not always this big.) It’s a symptom of grief that became a spiral of shame, and has gradually manifested in an apparent death wish. The film wheels out carts and carts of tragic backstory: an anguished grapple with sexuality, a lover lost to suicide, an abandoned family, an evangelical organization that played its damaging, judgmental part.
thumb_up
21 likes
L
The only pleasure Charlie seems to derive from life comes from rereading a personal scripture, an old student essay on Moby Dick from which the film draws its dual-meaning title. (His obsession with its unvarnished honesty is ironic in such a dishonest drama.) Adapting his own decade-old stage play, Baskets creator Samuel D.
thumb_up
27 likes
E
Hunter makes little attempt to disguise the theatrical origins of The Whale, which unfolds over what we’re led to understand might be the last few days of Charlie’s life. Hunter’s screenplay is an overheated stew of hot-button issues, tackled by a supporting cast of characters that keep entering right and exiting left at regular intervals, nudging Charlie toward acceptance or possible redemption. Among the ensemble of coming and going house guests is Charlie’s longtime friend, Liz (Downsizing’s Hong Chau), a nurse who checks up on him regularly, lecturing him about his health while also acquiescing to his pleas for unhealthy food.
thumb_up
33 likes
J
Hong is so tough and vulnerable and authentic in the role, it’s a shame she’s playing a character who can’t stop spilling her guts via torturously overwritten monologues. There’s also Thomas (Ty Simpkins), a young, fresh-faced missionary who rather conveniently wanders into the narrative and becomes determined to save Charlie’s soul before it departs.
thumb_up
25 likes
G
(Naturally, he has some demons of his own.) Most prominent is the protagonist’s estranged daughter, Ellie (Sadie Sink, best known as Max from Stranger Things), who he abandoned to start a new life years earlier. Given those sad circumstances, it’s kind of impressive how unsympathetic The Whale manages to make her. She’s a veritable cartoon of venomous teen angst, hurling slurs and cyberbullying insults at anyone in her proximity.
thumb_up
39 likes
V
That last subplot, a bad-dad quest for forgiveness, recalls Aronofsky’s earlier The Wrestler, another portrait of a damaged man pushing his body to life-threatening extremes. One could, in fact, call corporeal abuse a regular theme of this hots-hot auteur’s work, mirrored by the hangnail-pulling ballerina meltdown of Black Swan and the spiraling eating-disorder addiction Ellen Burstyn endures in Requiem for a Dream.
thumb_up
26 likes
A
Here again, the director can’t resist indulging his fascination with grotesquerie. The Whale isn’t explicitly an act of callous fat-shaming, as some have declared the movie sight unseen; its aim is empathy. But too often does Aronofsky’s compassion curdle into a kind of nightmare pity, gazing upon Charlie as he masturbates on his couch in a state of co-mingled agony and pleasure, or as he desperately binges by the glow of his fridge.
thumb_up
28 likes
G
Not that Fraser ever seems to be begging for pity. Grabbing maybe his meatiest role ever, no pun intended, the one-time A-list heartthrob of The Mummy and George of the Jungle wrestles mightily with the limitations of the overheated material.
thumb_up
34 likes
J
For all the suffering the film pours on his character, the star refuses to play Charlie as a morose sob story. He brings a hint of suppressed mirth, and a light sensitivity that clashes productively with the heaviness of the material.
thumb_up
39 likes
M
Burying him in latex might be a kind of stunt casting, but Fraser never lets the artificial girth he dons do the acting for him. Instead, he lets us see glimmers of the carefree charisma that defined his derring-do star turns of a Hollywood lifetime ago.
thumb_up
36 likes
A
The impression is not of someone swallowed by their disorder, but of a soul still flickering beneath the pain that spurred it. But Fraser can’t overcome the contrivances, community-theater histrionics, or clanging artificial dialogue of Hunter’s play.
thumb_up
33 likes
W
Nor can Aronofsky, that inconsistent but always ambitious maestro of holy and earthly conflict. The Whale is easily his limpest drama, no matter how fully he commits to the black-box claustrophobia of the material or how incessantly Rob Simonsen’s operatic music swells and pleads.
thumb_up
3 likes
M
To get hung up on that cocoon of fake flesh Fraser inhabits is to miss the more essential shortcomings of the film. It wears it themes like shoddy prosthetics, a gimcrack illusion of profundity. The Whale opens in select theaters December 9. Our coverage of the Toronto International Film Festival continues all week. For more of A.A.
thumb_up
22 likes
S
Dowd’s writing, please visit his Authory page.
Editors' Recommendations
God’s Creatures review: an overly restrained Irish drama Father and daughter bond in the first trailer for Aftersun The Fabelmans review: an origin story of Steven Spielberg Happening review: A brutal but necessary drama Everything Everywhere All at Once review: A maximalist multiverse epic Return to Silent Hill officially announced by Konami The best boxing movies ever made Heardle today, October 20: Answer, hints, and help for song of the day (Thursday) Framed today, October 20: Answer and hints for the movie of the day (Thursday) Celebrate Back to the Future Day with special three-movie bundle sale from Vudu Nope to begin streaming on Peacock starting next month VCRs are long gone, but 2002’s The Ring is still as terrifying as ever Black Adam’s ending explained UFC PPV: How much is Oliveira vs.
thumb_up
5 likes
J
Makhachev? UFC 280 PPV Deal: Lock in now and save $50 on Oliveira vs. Makhachev All Quiet on the Western Front trailer exposes the horror of war Diana won’t go quietly in The Crown season 5 trailer The 74 best movies on Amazon Prime right now (October 2022)
thumb_up
50 likes
Similar Discussions
-
Even I don t know who that tennis player is only know legends of tennis Roger Federer Rafael Nadal K pop fans troll Casper Ruud after he denies listening to BTS music
-
WWE star Kevin Owens discloses which NXT duo he would call upon
-
Luis Campos and the president are working on it Christophe Galtier reveals PSG s plans for winter transfer window
-
I don t make any fuss PSG manager Christophe Galtier opens up on alleged rocky relationship between Kylian Mbappe and Neymar
-
Backstage reason why WWE had Drew McIntyre lose to Roman Reigns at Clash at the Castle in front of his home crowd Reports
-
Players Can Move in Pokémon GO Without Walking Details
-
My Hero Academia Chapter 348 Breakdown The News Pocket
-
Gold Roger Didn t Have Devil Fruit Kaido Confirms in Latest One Piece Spoilers The News Pocket
-
Imágenes y Frase para Whatsapp APK Download for Android
-
Patrimoni APK Download for Android
-
Battle Shooting FPS Gun Games APK Download for Android
-
Quiz Words Money Heist APK Download for Android
-
Couple de Fran ais disparus au Mexique deux corps sans vie retrouv s dans une auberge seraient ceux de Michel et Assya Faits Divers
-
La Russie n a aucun moyen de gagner cette guerre assure un v t ran du Groupe Wagner
-
Meta un an apr s le m tavers toujours bloqu sur la piste de d collage Presse conomique Actualit
-
Fran ois Civil donne de la voix pour Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2
-
Un film de No l avec Lindsay Lohan ? Netflix l a fait et on a trop h te
-
GOP s Budd pulls ahead in N C Senate showdown Beasley enlists Dave Matthews to energize Dem voters B Politics B Biden
-
F1 Drivers Want FIA to Bring the Hammer Down on Cost Cap Offenders
-
Discovering the place on the Colorado where water becomes river
-
Dear Justice Department Send help now River All Mobile
-
Queer Military Tale The Inspection Feels Equally Personal Vivid and Trite Nyff 60 Bokeem Woodbine
-
Los libros m s vendidos 21 de octubre de 2022 Libros Literatura
-
S nchez abucheado crecimiento versus recuperaci n Columnas De Opini n Econom a
-
Izertis ciberseguridad transversal para una metamorfosis digital Seguridad İnternet Internet
-
Bleach Thousand Year Blood War Episode 2 review Hueco Mundo devastated Dexerto
-
Roblox All Bobo Locations in Evade The Nerd Stash
-
Pokemon Go The Best Movesets and Counters for Hypno
-
Elden Ring How to Defeat Malekith the Black Blade The Nerd Stash
-
Dropshipping Niches That Are Profitable Not Trendy 2022