igforum.bio / experts-say-a-mix-of-touchscreen-and-physical-controls-are-best-for-drivers - 99579
L
%Begin Experts Say a Mix of Touchscreen and Physical Controls are Best for Drivers GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Search Close GO News &gt; Smart & Connected Life <h1> Experts Say a Mix of Touchscreen and Physical Controls are Best for Drivers</h1> <h2> Looking cool doesn’t make touchscreens better</h2> By Oliver Haslam Oliver Haslam Oliver Haslam is a freelance tech reporter for Lifewire, having written for iMore, How to Geek, Macworld, PC Mag, and many more for more than 10 years.
Lucas Martinez Moderator
access_time 5 minutes ago
%Begin Experts Say a Mix of Touchscreen and Physical Controls are Best for Drivers GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Search Close GO News > Smart & Connected Life

Experts Say a Mix of Touchscreen and Physical Controls are Best for Drivers

Looking cool doesn’t make touchscreens better

By Oliver Haslam Oliver Haslam Oliver Haslam is a freelance tech reporter for Lifewire, having written for iMore, How to Geek, Macworld, PC Mag, and many more for more than 10 years.
thumb_up Like (26)
comment Reply (2)
share Share
visibility 721 views
thumb_up 26 likes
comment 2 replies
A
Aria Nguyen 4 minutes ago
lifewire's editorial guidelines Updated on August 29, 2022 08:15AM EDT Fact checked by Jerri Ledford...
A
Andrew Wilson 5 minutes ago
lifewire's fact checking process Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Smart & Connected Life Mobile P...
B
lifewire's editorial guidelines Updated on August 29, 2022 08:15AM EDT Fact checked by Jerri Ledford Fact checked by Jerri Ledford Western Kentucky University Gulf Coast Community College Jerri L. Ledford has been writing, editing, and fact-checking tech stories since 1994. Her work has appeared in Computerworld, PC Magazine, Information Today, and many others.
Brandon Kumar Member
access_time 8 minutes ago
lifewire's editorial guidelines Updated on August 29, 2022 08:15AM EDT Fact checked by Jerri Ledford Fact checked by Jerri Ledford Western Kentucky University Gulf Coast Community College Jerri L. Ledford has been writing, editing, and fact-checking tech stories since 1994. Her work has appeared in Computerworld, PC Magazine, Information Today, and many others.
thumb_up Like (36)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 36 likes
comment 3 replies
S
Scarlett Brown 4 minutes ago
lifewire's fact checking process Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Smart & Connected Life Mobile P...
S
Scarlett Brown 7 minutes ago
Research by Swedish auto magazine Vi Bilägare looked at how long it took drivers to carry out basic...
Show 1 more replies
H
lifewire's fact checking process Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Smart & Connected Life Mobile Phones Internet & Security Computers & Tablets Smart Life Home Theater & Entertainment Software & Apps Social Media Streaming Gaming New tests show that drivers take longer to carry out tasks with touchscreens than with physical controls.Cars with physical controls are being phased out in favor of all-screen interfaces.A hybrid system of touchscreen and physical buttons might be the best solution, allowing tactile control and a live interface when required. Glenn Lindberg / Vi Bilägare New tests show that drivers are safer when they ditch touchscreens for physical controls, but that doesn’t mean we should forgo them altogether, experts say.
Henry Schmidt Member
access_time 6 minutes ago
lifewire's fact checking process Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Smart & Connected Life Mobile Phones Internet & Security Computers & Tablets Smart Life Home Theater & Entertainment Software & Apps Social Media Streaming Gaming New tests show that drivers take longer to carry out tasks with touchscreens than with physical controls.Cars with physical controls are being phased out in favor of all-screen interfaces.A hybrid system of touchscreen and physical buttons might be the best solution, allowing tactile control and a live interface when required. Glenn Lindberg / Vi Bilägare New tests show that drivers are safer when they ditch touchscreens for physical controls, but that doesn’t mean we should forgo them altogether, experts say.
thumb_up Like (30)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 30 likes
comment 3 replies
L
Liam Wilson 3 minutes ago
Research by Swedish auto magazine Vi Bilägare looked at how long it took drivers to carry out basic...
K
Kevin Wang 3 minutes ago
Experts agree touchscreens can be problematic, but they have positives, too. “Physical buttons are...
Show 1 more replies
D
Research by Swedish auto magazine Vi Bilägare looked at how long it took drivers to carry out basic in-car interactions while driving various cars that featured large touchscreen interfaces. A 17-year-old Volvo V70 was also added as the control, a vehicle with no touchscreen, relying instead on old-fashioned buttons and knobs. Cars with touchscreens require the driver to look away from the road for significantly longer periods than when driving the analog vehicle.
Daniel Kumar Member
access_time 4 minutes ago
Research by Swedish auto magazine Vi Bilägare looked at how long it took drivers to carry out basic in-car interactions while driving various cars that featured large touchscreen interfaces. A 17-year-old Volvo V70 was also added as the control, a vehicle with no touchscreen, relying instead on old-fashioned buttons and knobs. Cars with touchscreens require the driver to look away from the road for significantly longer periods than when driving the analog vehicle.
thumb_up Like (37)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 37 likes
A
Experts agree touchscreens can be problematic, but they have positives, too. “Physical buttons are good for very short (and especially binary) tasks,” Chris Schreiner, a director at UX Syndicated Research, agreed when speaking with Lifewire via email. “A good vehicle uses a mix of [different] types of interfaces, optimizing each.” One of those interfaces wasn’t tested by Vi Bilägare and could hold the answer.
Alexander Wang Member
access_time 15 minutes ago
Experts agree touchscreens can be problematic, but they have positives, too. “Physical buttons are good for very short (and especially binary) tasks,” Chris Schreiner, a director at UX Syndicated Research, agreed when speaking with Lifewire via email. “A good vehicle uses a mix of [different] types of interfaces, optimizing each.” One of those interfaces wasn’t tested by Vi Bilägare and could hold the answer.
thumb_up Like (33)
comment Reply (3)
thumb_up 33 likes
comment 3 replies
N
Noah Davis 10 minutes ago
“Voice is (supposed to be) good for more complex tasks like searching for media or setting a desti...
E
Evelyn Zhang 13 minutes ago
A Tesla Model 3 was also included — the vehicle is known for its large touchscreen and having very...
Show 1 more replies
A
“Voice is (supposed to be) good for more complex tasks like searching for media or setting a destination in your satnav.” <h2> Cold Hard Numbers </h2> Peter Dazeley / Getty Images During its testing, Vi Bilägare had someone carry out a number of in-car tasks while driving around an airfield at 110 km/h (68 mph.) Cars from numerous manufacturers were included in the test, with BMW, Dacia, Hyundai, and Mercedes just some of those involved. The cars chosen included both budget (Dacia) and luxury (Mercedes, BMW) models, with the mid-range also represented by a number of other manufacturers.
Aria Nguyen Member
access_time 30 minutes ago
“Voice is (supposed to be) good for more complex tasks like searching for media or setting a destination in your satnav.”

Cold Hard Numbers

Peter Dazeley / Getty Images During its testing, Vi Bilägare had someone carry out a number of in-car tasks while driving around an airfield at 110 km/h (68 mph.) Cars from numerous manufacturers were included in the test, with BMW, Dacia, Hyundai, and Mercedes just some of those involved. The cars chosen included both budget (Dacia) and luxury (Mercedes, BMW) models, with the mid-range also represented by a number of other manufacturers.
thumb_up Like (23)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 23 likes
J
A Tesla Model 3 was also included — the vehicle is known for its large touchscreen and having very few physical controls throughout its entire cabin. A hybrid solution would work best when people have a main task like driving to do. Vi Bilägare’s suite of tasks required the driver to activate the vehicle’s heated seat, turn on the radio, reset the trip computer, and more but none of the tasks were extraordinary and were likely to be things carried out during daily driving.
Julia Zhang Member
access_time 21 minutes ago
A Tesla Model 3 was also included — the vehicle is known for its large touchscreen and having very few physical controls throughout its entire cabin. A hybrid solution would work best when people have a main task like driving to do. Vi Bilägare’s suite of tasks required the driver to activate the vehicle’s heated seat, turn on the radio, reset the trip computer, and more but none of the tasks were extraordinary and were likely to be things carried out during daily driving.
thumb_up Like (0)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 0 likes
comment 1 replies
T
Thomas Anderson 19 minutes ago
In terms of results, the 2005 Volvo V70 required that the driver spend just ten seconds pressing but...
A
In terms of results, the 2005 Volvo V70 required that the driver spend just ten seconds pressing buttons and twiddling knobs. The vehicle traveled 306 meters during that time.
Amelia Singh Moderator
access_time 8 minutes ago
In terms of results, the 2005 Volvo V70 required that the driver spend just ten seconds pressing buttons and twiddling knobs. The vehicle traveled 306 meters during that time.
thumb_up Like (44)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 44 likes
comment 1 replies
J
James Smith 4 minutes ago
By contrast, the MG Marvel R performed the worst, requiring a full 44.6 seconds to do the same tasks...
W
By contrast, the MG Marvel R performed the worst, requiring a full 44.6 seconds to do the same tasks and traveling 1,372 meters during that period. The only modern car that came close to matching its analog rival was the Volvo C40 (13.7 seconds and 417 meters.) <h2> A Matter of Safety </h2> Vi Bilägare Taking attention away from the road has the potential to cause accidents, but distractions come in many forms. Research carried out by the Transport Research Laboratory (TRL) found that drivers normally react to something within just one second when they are paying full attention to the road.
William Brown Member
access_time 27 minutes ago
By contrast, the MG Marvel R performed the worst, requiring a full 44.6 seconds to do the same tasks and traveling 1,372 meters during that period. The only modern car that came close to matching its analog rival was the Volvo C40 (13.7 seconds and 417 meters.)

A Matter of Safety

Vi Bilägare Taking attention away from the road has the potential to cause accidents, but distractions come in many forms. Research carried out by the Transport Research Laboratory (TRL) found that drivers normally react to something within just one second when they are paying full attention to the road.
thumb_up Like (14)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 14 likes
J
That time increased by 57% when using an in-car touchscreen, a figure higher than when texting (35%) and having a legal amount of alcohol in their system (12%.) Neale Kinnear, TRL’s head of behavioral science, reported that “taking your eyes off the road for two seconds can double the risk of having a crash, yet a driver can spend up to 20 seconds looking at a touchscreen to perform a simple task.” <h2> Don t Ditch Screens Just Yet </h2> Lu ShaoJi / Getty Images <br/>Some experts believe it would be a mistake to go back to an age when buttons were the only way to control cars. Instead, they think that a hybrid system of touchscreens and well-placed physical controls could be the answer carmakers have been looking for. "Most people use a touch screen mobile device without much difficulty," Reginé Gilbert, an Industry Assistant Professor at NYI Tandon School of Engineering and a teacher of UX design at General Assembly, told Lifewire via email.
James Smith Moderator
access_time 50 minutes ago
That time increased by 57% when using an in-car touchscreen, a figure higher than when texting (35%) and having a legal amount of alcohol in their system (12%.) Neale Kinnear, TRL’s head of behavioral science, reported that “taking your eyes off the road for two seconds can double the risk of having a crash, yet a driver can spend up to 20 seconds looking at a touchscreen to perform a simple task.”

Don t Ditch Screens Just Yet

Lu ShaoJi / Getty Images
Some experts believe it would be a mistake to go back to an age when buttons were the only way to control cars. Instead, they think that a hybrid system of touchscreens and well-placed physical controls could be the answer carmakers have been looking for. "Most people use a touch screen mobile device without much difficulty," Reginé Gilbert, an Industry Assistant Professor at NYI Tandon School of Engineering and a teacher of UX design at General Assembly, told Lifewire via email.
thumb_up Like (13)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 13 likes
comment 1 replies
E
Evelyn Zhang 19 minutes ago
"Driving with touchscreens can be a distraction and a danger." But that doesn't mean that touchscree...
H
"Driving with touchscreens can be a distraction and a danger." But that doesn't mean that touchscreens don't have their place. &#34;A hybrid solution would work best when people have a main task like driving to do,&#34; added Gilbert. &#34;Tactile solutions give someone the ability to feel something without having to look at it.
Hannah Kim Member
access_time 22 minutes ago
"Driving with touchscreens can be a distraction and a danger." But that doesn't mean that touchscreens don't have their place. "A hybrid solution would work best when people have a main task like driving to do," added Gilbert. "Tactile solutions give someone the ability to feel something without having to look at it.
thumb_up Like (31)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 31 likes
E
Touch screens are definitely better suited for some things more than others.&#34; Florens Verschelde, a UX engineer with StackBlitz, believes carmakers should look to another industry for inspiration when mixing physical controls with virtual ones. "[This is] why pro cameras have physical dials, not touchscreen-first UIs—but it did not stop some manufacturers from putting car controls behind a touchscreen," they wrote on Twitter.<br> Was this page helpful?
Elijah Patel Member
access_time 60 minutes ago
Touch screens are definitely better suited for some things more than others." Florens Verschelde, a UX engineer with StackBlitz, believes carmakers should look to another industry for inspiration when mixing physical controls with virtual ones. "[This is] why pro cameras have physical dials, not touchscreen-first UIs—but it did not stop some manufacturers from putting car controls behind a touchscreen," they wrote on Twitter.
Was this page helpful?
thumb_up Like (44)
comment Reply (1)
thumb_up 44 likes
comment 1 replies
D
David Cohen 33 minutes ago
Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subscribe Tell us why!...
J
Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subscribe Tell us why!
Jack Thompson Member
access_time 65 minutes ago
Thanks for letting us know! Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day Subscribe Tell us why!
thumb_up Like (27)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 27 likes
A
Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire Apple Car: News and Expected Price, Release Date, Specs; and More Rumors How to Enable the Touchscreen in Windows 10 What Android Auto Is and How to Use It How Does Lane Centering Work? 9 Things to Consider Before Buying a Dash Cam The 7 Best Dash Cams of 2022 Should You Buy a Dash Cam? What Is a Touchscreen and How Do They Work?
Alexander Wang Member
access_time 14 minutes ago
Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire Apple Car: News and Expected Price, Release Date, Specs; and More Rumors How to Enable the Touchscreen in Windows 10 What Android Auto Is and How to Use It How Does Lane Centering Work? 9 Things to Consider Before Buying a Dash Cam The 7 Best Dash Cams of 2022 Should You Buy a Dash Cam? What Is a Touchscreen and How Do They Work?
thumb_up Like (35)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 35 likes
S
How to Disable the Touchscreen in Windows 11 Are Self-Driving Cars Legal in Your State? Electronic Stability Control and ESC Failure What Can You Do With Android’s Driving Mode?
Scarlett Brown Member
access_time 45 minutes ago
How to Disable the Touchscreen in Windows 11 Are Self-Driving Cars Legal in Your State? Electronic Stability Control and ESC Failure What Can You Do With Android’s Driving Mode?
thumb_up Like (20)
comment Reply (0)
thumb_up 20 likes
I
Get Internet in Your Car With a Mobile Hotspot Would Your Car Survive An EMP Attack? The 7 Best Remote Control Cars of 2022 5 Teen Driving Apps to Keep Your Child Safe Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies
Isaac Schmidt Member
access_time 80 minutes ago
Get Internet in Your Car With a Mobile Hotspot Would Your Car Survive An EMP Attack? The 7 Best Remote Control Cars of 2022 5 Teen Driving Apps to Keep Your Child Safe Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies
thumb_up Like (50)
comment Reply (2)
thumb_up 50 likes
comment 2 replies
E
Elijah Patel 54 minutes ago
Experts Say a Mix of Touchscreen and Physical Controls are Best for Drivers GA S REGULAR Menu Lifewi...
A
Andrew Wilson 37 minutes ago
lifewire's editorial guidelines Updated on August 29, 2022 08:15AM EDT Fact checked by Jerri Ledford...

Write a Reply

Similar Discussions