%Begin Domestic Abuse Survivor Who Won Landmark Supreme Court Case Is Found Dead in Her Home Isacco Jacky Saada - Sonia Sotomayor HEAD TOPICS
Domestic Abuse Survivor Who Won Landmark Supreme Court Case Is Found Dead in Her Home
10/21/2022 9:56:00 PM
Domestic Abuse Survivor Who Won Landmark Supreme Court Case Is Found Dead in Her Home
Isacco Jacky Saada Sonia Sotomayor
Source
Jezebel
Domestic Abuse Survivor Who Won Landmark Supreme Court Case Is Found Dead in Her Home
Last month, Narkis Golan made the chilling observation on Facebook that “many women end up dead” in cases like hers. “Why does the system ENABLE such a person to continue to cause my son and I harm through the courts after surviving such abuse,” she continued, before making the chilling observation that “many women end up dead” in cases like hers.
thumb_upLike (6)
commentReply (3)
shareShare
visibility614 views
thumb_up6 likes
comment
3 replies
E
Evelyn Zhang 2 minutes ago
“People call me a survivor. What have I survived when I’m still fighting for my human rights tha...
J
Julia Zhang 3 minutes ago
In anfilingsa “get,” or a Jewish religious marriage divorce, from Saada, her husband since 2014,...
“People call me a survivor. What have I survived when I’m still fighting for my human rights that has been stripped away from me for so many years while the real criminal gets to live his best life knowing he still holds that power over my head?”
Golas was found dead this week, a little over a month after her impassioned Facebook post.
thumb_upLike (45)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up45 likes
comment
3 replies
D
Daniel Kumar 6 minutes ago
In anfilingsa “get,” or a Jewish religious marriage divorce, from Saada, her husband since 2014,...
M
Madison Singh 2 minutes ago
Select from our newsletters below and enter your email to subscribe. Read more >> This is so sad and...
In anfilingsa “get,” or a Jewish religious marriage divorce, from Saada, her husband since 2014, but he refused unless she returned to Italy with their child. Legal representatives for Saada did not immediately respond to requests for comment about Golan’s death by phone and email. Read more: Jezebel » Police searching for driver who caused deadly hit-and-run crash on Katy Freeway last month Megan Hilty's Raising $50K to Recover Her Family's Bodies After Crash Trevor Noah Announces New Stand-up Special I Wish You Would Cops looking for man who allegedly snuck into store bathroom to record woman
Hacking - CNN
CNN News, delivered.
thumb_upLike (16)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up16 likes
comment
2 replies
L
Lucas Martinez 10 minutes ago
Select from our newsletters below and enter your email to subscribe. Read more >> This is so sad and...
A
Amelia Singh 9 minutes ago
Megan Hilty's Raising $50K to Recover Her Family's Bodies After CrashThe actress' pregna...
E
Ethan Thomas Member
access_time
20 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Select from our newsletters below and enter your email to subscribe. Read more >> This is so sad and it happens so often to domestic abuse survivors. 😣
Police searching for driver who caused deadly hit-and-run crash on Katy Freeway last monthThe Houston Police Department and Crime Stoppers need the public’s help finding the person responsible for a deadly hit-and-run crash on the Katy Freeway.
thumb_upLike (29)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up29 likes
comment
2 replies
N
Nathan Chen 1 minutes ago
Megan Hilty's Raising $50K to Recover Her Family's Bodies After CrashThe actress' pregna...
C
Charlotte Lee 9 minutes ago
Why Clare Crawley and Ryan Dawkins Had 3 Proposals and Want 2 WeddingsClare Crawley is making sure t...
M
Mia Anderson Member
access_time
10 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Megan Hilty's Raising $50K to Recover Her Family's Bodies After CrashThe actress' pregnant sister, brother-in-law and nephew died in a plane crash last month. Trevor Noah Announces New Stand-up Special I Wish You WouldTrevor Noah announces his new Netflix stand-up special I Wish You Would. Cops looking for man who allegedly snuck into store bathroom to record womanThe incident took place in Burlington County last month, police said.
thumb_upLike (20)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up20 likes
comment
3 replies
A
Amelia Singh 3 minutes ago
Why Clare Crawley and Ryan Dawkins Had 3 Proposals and Want 2 WeddingsClare Crawley is making sure t...
M
Madison Singh 2 minutes ago
Migrants would like to work in the US and then go back home but our current system doesn’t allow t...
Why Clare Crawley and Ryan Dawkins Had 3 Proposals and Want 2 WeddingsClare Crawley is making sure to celebrate all of her relationship's special moments with her mom. Fewer Americans apply for jobless benefits last weekThe number of Americans applying for unemployment benefits fell last week and remains historically low even as the U.S. economy slows in the midst of decades-high inflation.
thumb_upLike (11)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up11 likes
comment
1 replies
C
Charlotte Lee 2 minutes ago
Migrants would like to work in the US and then go back home but our current system doesn’t allow t...
J
Julia Zhang Member
access_time
28 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Migrants would like to work in the US and then go back home but our current system doesn’t allow that. It needs to be fixed.
thumb_upLike (5)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up5 likes
E
Elijah Patel Member
access_time
16 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Facebook post .On Monday, Sept.Megan Hilty Is Raising $50K to Recover Pregnant Sister and Nephew's Bodies After Plane Crash By 3:19 PM PDT, October 19, 2022 This video is unavailable because we were unable to load a message from our sponsors., South African comedian Trevor Noah is announcing his third Netflix stand-up special, I Wish You Would , out on November 22. “After winning at the Supreme Court, I had to yet again face the same unsympathetic judge who wants to force my son back to a country where I was tortured, raped and abused in every way,” Golan wrote.
thumb_upLike (3)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up3 likes
M
Mia Anderson Member
access_time
27 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
“There was never justice for me.m. All I can do is try to be the best mommy I can while fighting this battle that makes no sense.
thumb_upLike (44)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up44 likes
E
Ethan Thomas Member
access_time
20 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
I just keep asking myself WHY??” Advertisement “Why does the system ENABLE such a person to continue to cause my son and I harm through the courts after surviving such abuse,” she continued, before making the chilling observation that “many women end up dead” in cases like hers. Officers said Bobbie Joseph Alan Payne was traveling westbound when he was hit by an unknown person’s vehicle.
thumb_upLike (7)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up7 likes
C
Charlotte Lee Member
access_time
22 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
“People call me a survivor. But who knows, maybe he improves in a more conventional stand-up setting (not that we’re holding our breath)? Noah’s previous Netflix specials include Son of Patricia.
thumb_upLike (50)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up50 likes
comment
2 replies
E
Ella Rodriguez 1 minutes ago
What have I survived when I’m still fighting for my human rights that has been stripped away from ...
W
William Brown 18 minutes ago
Investigators said the suspect fled the scene without rendering aid to Payne. She concluded, “I pr...
E
Evelyn Zhang Member
access_time
36 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
What have I survived when I’m still fighting for my human rights that has been stripped away from me for so many years while the real criminal gets to live his best life knowing he still holds that power over my head?” “Why must I be threatened and silenced by the system that’s meant to protect us? Why? I’m just trying to give my son the life he deserves,” Golan wrote.
thumb_upLike (1)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up1 likes
comment
2 replies
R
Ryan Garcia 2 minutes ago
Investigators said the suspect fled the scene without rendering aid to Payne. She concluded, “I pr...
S
Sophie Martin 4 minutes ago
I want the world to know the truth. Crime Stoppers may pay up to $5,000 for information leading to t...
W
William Brown Member
access_time
52 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Investigators said the suspect fled the scene without rendering aid to Payne. She concluded, “I probably won’t ever have those answers but one thing I know for sure is that I won’t stop fighting and from now on, I won’t be silenced either.
thumb_upLike (35)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up35 likes
comment
1 replies
S
Sophia Chen 25 minutes ago
I want the world to know the truth. Crime Stoppers may pay up to $5,000 for information leading to t...
A
Amelia Singh Moderator
access_time
42 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
I want the world to know the truth. Crime Stoppers may pay up to $5,000 for information leading to the charging and/or arrest of the suspect(s) in this case.” Advertisement Golas was found dead this week, a little over a month after her impassioned Facebook post. In an of a conversation between Saada and Golan shared with the public on Thursday, Saada can be heard telling Golan that he’s well connected to judges and courts in Italy amid their ongoing legal fight.
thumb_upLike (2)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up2 likes
comment
2 replies
R
Ryan Garcia 29 minutes ago
Only tips and calls DIRECTLY TO Crime Stoppers are anonymous and eligible for a cash reward . In Gol...
A
Ava White 7 minutes ago
About the Author:.S. for her brother’s wedding in 2018, instead of returning to Italy, she took re...
L
Luna Park Member
access_time
15 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Only tips and calls DIRECTLY TO Crime Stoppers are anonymous and eligible for a cash reward . In Golan’s legal filings , she’d accused Saada of pushing, slapping, and grabbing her, often in front of their son, and even making threats against her life. When Golan took their son to the U.
thumb_upLike (32)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up32 likes
A
Alexander Wang Member
access_time
16 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
About the Author:.S. for her brother’s wedding in 2018, instead of returning to Italy, she took refuge in a local domestic violence shelter.
thumb_upLike (16)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up16 likes
comment
1 replies
H
Hannah Kim 1 minutes ago
Golan sought a “get,” or a Jewish religious marriage divorce, from Saada, her husband since 2014...
L
Lucas Martinez Moderator
access_time
17 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Golan sought a “get,” or a Jewish religious marriage divorce, from Saada, her husband since 2014, but he refused unless she returned to Italy with their child. Legal representatives for Saada did not immediately respond to requests for comment about Golan’s death by phone and email. Advertisement Golan never gave in to Saada’s demands.
thumb_upLike (43)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up43 likes
comment
1 replies
A
Amelia Singh 11 minutes ago
“The most admirable thing is that, no matter how exhausted she was, no matter how many times she c...
J
Joseph Kim Member
access_time
18 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
“The most admirable thing is that, no matter how exhausted she was, no matter how many times she called me, day or night, to cry about it, or just say, ‘It’s so heavy, it’s so heavy’—no matter how many times, she’d just continue,” Morin said. “She was trying to protect her son from a great evil.
thumb_upLike (48)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up48 likes
comment
1 replies
T
Thomas Anderson 6 minutes ago
Giving up was never an option, for her family, for her child, and not only her child, but for all th...
S
Sofia Garcia Member
access_time
57 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Giving up was never an option, for her family, for her child, and not only her child, but for all the women who were reaching out to her telling their stories. There is nothing she would not do for her son and the women and kids she was fighting for.” Advertisement Fidler told Jezebel that from the beginning, Golan insisted that she wanted to change the law for children and mothers like her, called “ Hague Moms ,” who flee their countries of origin with their children to escape abuse only to face legal retaliation from abusers, who weaponize the Hague Convention’s child abduction clauses. “She always would say, ‘We’re going up to the Supreme Court,’ and the lawyers on her case were always a little skeptical, because we knew the odds,” Fidler said.
thumb_upLike (42)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up42 likes
K
Kevin Wang Member
access_time
80 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
The Supreme Court accepts about 1% of cases. “But she knew this was a fight worth fighting, even if everything—financially, the whole court system—was stacked against her. ” “She was the survivor of such extreme abuse and control, and she’s a survivor of the court system too, which is a very difficult and challenging place for survivors of domestic violence,” Fidler told me.
thumb_upLike (1)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up1 likes
N
Noah Davis Member
access_time
63 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
“Her legacy is the Supreme Court case.” Advertisement The Supreme Court ruling in Golan’s favor marked a crucial victory for domestic abuse victims like Golan and their children, who seek refuge in the U.S., moving forward. Previously, a precedent set by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit required that children should be returned to the country of their habitual residence, despite risk of facing abuse, if there are any “ameliorative measures” that can reduce the risk of abuse.
thumb_upLike (31)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up31 likes
A
Andrew Wilson Member
access_time
88 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Before Golan’s case went to the Supreme Court, a U.S. district court and the Second Circuit ruled that her son had to be returned to his father in Italy because measures could, theoretically, be taken to reduce the risk of harm to the child—namely, the district court ruled, Saada could be required to go to therapy, drop criminal charges against Golan, and pay her $20,000 for the return of their son.
thumb_upLike (29)
commentReply (1)
thumb_up29 likes
comment
1 replies
A
Amelia Singh 34 minutes ago
“What they did to her for the last five years of her life was just horrible, forcing her to experi...
C
Christopher Lee Member
access_time
92 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
“What they did to her for the last five years of her life was just horrible, forcing her to experience such heaviness, such mental, emotional exhaustion, even after acknowledging the abuse,” Morin said. In the Supreme Court’s decision to reverse these prior rulings, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that “a court is not bound to order a child’s return if it finds that return would put the child at a grave risk of physical or psychological harm,” and that courts aren’t required to examine all possible ameliorative measures in order to deny a Hague Convention petition for a child’s return.
thumb_upLike (7)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up7 likes
comment
2 replies
J
Jack Thompson 77 minutes ago
Advertisement wrote in a Thursday Facebook post that the two had “become good friends” over the ...
S
Sophia Chen 35 minutes ago
” Advertisement “She would FaceTime me at all hours of the day and night and I would just listen...
S
Scarlett Brown Member
access_time
120 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Advertisement wrote in a Thursday Facebook post that the two had “become good friends” over the course of her case. He acknowledged that “as of now… there were no signs of foul play” in Golan’s death, but said he’s “spoken to homicide detectives and asked them to look into it further.
thumb_upLike (25)
commentReply (3)
thumb_up25 likes
comment
3 replies
J
Julia Zhang 33 minutes ago
” Advertisement “She would FaceTime me at all hours of the day and night and I would just listen...
W
William Brown 44 minutes ago
She helped me in so many other ways by connecting me with other moms.” Indeed, Golan’s Facebook ...
” Advertisement “She would FaceTime me at all hours of the day and night and I would just listen to her struggle and fight to keep Bradley,” Abbott wrote. “[Golan] wanted to be in my film on Hague Moms but was scared of what may happen if she spoke out.
thumb_upLike (36)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up36 likes
J
Julia Zhang Member
access_time
104 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
She helped me in so many other ways by connecting me with other moms.” Indeed, Golan’s Facebook page features post after post lifting up the stories of mothers and survivors trying to protect their kids and how her friends and followers could help them. That, Morin says, was just who Golan was.
thumb_upLike (10)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up10 likes
comment
2 replies
W
William Brown 39 minutes ago
“She was a warrior. She paved the way for all the people that are in that situation, for them and ...
T
Thomas Anderson 31 minutes ago
Advertisement “She didn’t get to stick around for the feeling of being free, of not being in mis...
J
Joseph Kim Member
access_time
135 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
“She was a warrior. She paved the way for all the people that are in that situation, for them and their kids to be safer.” It pains Morin that her sister “only had a moment to experience that freedom from the Supreme Court’s ruling.” And now, she never will.
thumb_upLike (2)
commentReply (0)
thumb_up2 likes
H
Henry Schmidt Member
access_time
28 minutes ago
Thursday, 08 May 2025
Advertisement “She didn’t get to stick around for the feeling of being free, of not being in misery, not feeling like her every move was watched,” Morin said. “She couldn’t take her son to Disney. She couldn’t do these things with her kid that she wanted to do.” .
thumb_upLike (29)
commentReply (2)
thumb_up29 likes
comment
2 replies
J
Joseph Kim 22 minutes ago
Domestic Abuse Survivor Who Won Landmark Supreme Court Case Is Found Dead in Her Home Isacco Jacky ...
S
Sophie Martin 1 minutes ago
“People call me a survivor. What have I survived when I’m still fighting for my human rights tha...