S
%Begin Copyright Office Ruling Issues Sweeping Right to Repair Reforms iFixit News Ana içeriğe geç Eşyalarını Tamir Et Topluluk Mağaza Legislation
visibility
243 views
thumb_up
26 likes
C
There's an obscure aspect of copyright law that is being abused by big manufacturers to take away our ability to fix things. In 2001, Sina Khanifar, a young entrepreneur, was sued by a cell phone manufacturer citing section 1201 of the DMCA, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Simply stated, 1201 makes it illegal to 'circumvent' locks put on products by the manufacturer without permission.
thumb_up
44 likes
K
It shifts control of our products from us, the owners, to the original makers of the equipment. This law has been a significant contributor to the steady erosion of ownership rights. Over the last twenty years, section 1201 has become notorious for stripping away the freedom of security researchers, cell phone recyclers, and farmers.
thumb_up
40 likes
T
Right now, General Motors is suing popular auto parts company Dorman for copyright infringement for selling aftermarket transmissions. Fortunately, Congress built an escape hatch into section 1201, allowing citizens to petition for exemptions to the extraordinarily broad law. So, every three years, someone has to go and ask for the right to tinker with our stuff.
thumb_up
34 likes
E
I’m that someone-that’s why I was in LA. Left to right: Jay Saurik, Matt Zieminski, Cynthia Replogle, Kyle Wiens, Sina Khanifar, Robert Miranda, Kit Walsh, Cory Doctorow, Katharine Trendacosta On behalf of the iFixit community, I came to ask for permission to circumvent digital locks in order to fix our stuff. Fortunately, I wasn’t alone.
thumb_up
6 likes
G
Along with Robert and Matt representing Repair.org, I was joined by Cynthia Replogle, iFixit's rockstar lawyer. And Cory Doctorow, Kit Walsh, and Mitch Stoltz from the Electronic Frontier Foundation, as well as Jay 'Saurik' Freeman of Cydia iPhone jailbreaking fame. We also had help from Jef Pearlman and his team of students from Stanford's IP law clinic.
thumb_up
11 likes
E
Our allies were met with opposition from a variety of moneyed and acronymed interests-the MPAA, RIAA, and the Auto Alliance, to name a few. Over three full days in LA, we were grilled by the Copyright Office. They wanted details on how cell phone baseband processors work, how automotive telematics systems are different from OBD II diagnostics, why you can't simply swap in a new Blu-ray drive into an Xbox, and so forth.
thumb_up
16 likes
E
It was exhausting-for us and for them. But they had done their homework, and asked intelligent questions on a startling variety of topics. The final ruling was released today, along with 342 pages of background.
thumb_up
20 likes
A
Our work, and that of our allies, was cited extensively. The Copyright Office clearly understands the frustration that the repair community is experiencing.
thumb_up
24 likes
S
In the introduction to their ruling, they include this quote, "[i]t's my own damn car, I paid for it, I should be able to repair it or have the person of my choice do it for me." Unlike past rulings, this goes into effect immediately. Well, almost immediately.
thumb_up
26 likes
L
The new rules are the law of the land as of this Sunday, October 28. So let's break it down, and talk about what's illegal today that will be kosher come Sunday. (Oh, and here's the decision from 2015 for comparison.)
Major new freedoms
You can now jailbreak Alexa-powered hardware, and other similar gadgets-they call these 'Voice assistant devices.' You can unlock new phones, not just used ones.
thumb_up
28 likes
A
This is important for recyclers that get unopened consumer returns. We got a general exemption for repair of smartphones, home appliances, or home systems.
thumb_up
39 likes
H
This means that it's finally legal to root and fix the Revolv smart home hubs that Google bricked when they shut down the servers. Or pretty much any other home device. Repair of motorized land vehicles (including tractors) by modifying the software is now legal.
thumb_up
16 likes
Z
Importantly, this includes access to telematic diagnostic data-which was a major point of contention. It's now legal for third-parties to perform repair on behalf of the owner.
thumb_up
21 likes
E
This is hugely important for the American economy, where repair jobs represent 3% of overall employment.
The ruling was not without some bad news
Our game console repair petition was denied, meaning repairs of PS4 and Xbox One systems are going to stay expensive. Products that are not 'smartphones, home appliances, or home systems' or 'motorized land vehicles' are excluded.
thumb_up
20 likes
E
So boat and airplane owners are still out of luck. An exemption request by Bunnie Huang and EFF to bypass HDCP, the copy protection on HDMI for the purposes of expanding the TV ecosystem was denied.
thumb_up
41 likes
I
We are going to continue to have trouble making repair options available for Xbox and Playstation optical drives because they're cryptographically programmed at the factory. We asked for the ability to pair a replacement drive with an existing console. But the Copyright Office declined, stating that 'in many cases, manufacturer repair services will be widely available and adequate.' On behalf of gamers in rural communities around the country, I respectfully disagree.
thumb_up
49 likes
R
Taylor Swift and Telematics
You may find this hard to believe, but one major point of discussion at the hearing was whether letting people repair cars and tractors would allow them to pirate music and movies using the vehicle's entertainment systems. In their 2015 filing, John Deere speculated that farmers might pirate Taylor Swift music using their equipment. Fortunately, the Copyright Office saw through that argument: Most of opponents' concerns, while significant, primarily relate to accessing entertainment works through vehicle entertainment systems and related subscription services, not to repairing more functional software installed to facilitate vehicle operation, which may require bypassing TPMs that incidentally protect entertainment systems.
thumb_up
46 likes
E
This Ruling is not a Panacea
With those few exceptions, the Copyright Office went as far as they could in granting access to the repair community. There are still significant limits, though, that will need to be addressed by Congress. One of those being the law against 'trafficking' in circumvention tools.
thumb_up
10 likes
H
From today's filing, "limiting the exemption to individual owners threatens to render it effectively meaningless for those who lack the technical knowledge to access and manipulate increasingly complex embedded computer systems." Now that circumvention is required to perform repairs, and most repairs benefit from tools, we need to open up a market for developing and selling those tools. Legislation like Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren's Unlocking Technology Act would provide the clarity that tool developers need.
thumb_up
33 likes
N
It would also be helpful for service providers to codify the ability of third-parties to perform service.
A Groundbreaking Decision
Nowadays, just about everything has software.
thumb_up
9 likes
J
Your ability to fix and maintain the products you own is contingent on being able to modify that software. But our tooling hasn't kept up. For fear of prosecution, farmers and independent mechanics haven't developed their own software tools to maintain their equipment.
thumb_up
15 likes
A
Now, they can. This ruling doesn't make that tooling available to the public-we're going to need actual Right to Repair legislation for that. But it does make it legal to make your own tools.
thumb_up
4 likes
D
And that's a huge step in the right direction. This is a sweeping victory.
thumb_up
8 likes
A
It's the result of years of careful, painstakingly detailed work by the community. So pop a celebratory bottle, or maybe pop open a piece of household hardware this Sunday-we did it!
thumb_up
12 likes
D
The Fine Print
For those of you that want to put on your amateur-lawyer hat, here's the full text of the exemptions that are relevant to hardware tinkerers: (5) Computer programs that enable the following types of lawfully acquired wireless devices to connect to a wireless telecommunications network, when circumvention is undertaken solely in order to connect to a wireless telecommunications network and such connection is authorized by the operator of such network (i) Wireless telephone handsets (i.e., cellphones); (ii) All-purpose tablet computers; (iii) Portable mobile connectivity devices, such as mobile hotspots, removable wireless broadband modems, and similar devices; and (iv) Wearable wireless devices designed to be worn on the body, such as smartwatches or fitness devices. (6) Computer programs that enable smartphones and portable all-purpose mobile computing devices to execute lawfully obtained software applications, where circumvention is accomplished for the sole purpose of enabling interoperability of such applications with computer programs on the smartphone or device, or to permit removal of software from the smartphone or device. For purposes of this paragraph (b)(6), a "portable all-purpose mobile computing device" is a device that is primarily designed to run a wide variety of programs rather than for consumption of a particular type of media content, is equipped with an operating system primarily designed for mobile use, and is intended to be carried or worn by an individual.
thumb_up
39 likes
E
(7) Computer programs that enable smart televisions to execute lawfully obtained software applications, where circumvention is accomplished for the sole purpose of enabling interoperability of such applications with computer programs on the smart television. (8) Computer programs that enable voice assistant devices to execute lawfully obtained software applications, where circumvention is accomplished for the sole purpose of enabling interoperability of such applications with computer programs on the device, or to permit removal of software from the device, and is not accomplished for the purpose of gaining unauthorized access to other copyrighted works. For purposes of this paragraph (b)(8), a "voice assistant device" is a device that is primarily designed to run a wide variety of programs rather than for consumption of a particular type of media content, is designed to take user input primarily by voice, and is designed to be installed in a home or office.
thumb_up
11 likes
N
(9) Computer programs that are contained in and control the functioning of a lawfully acquired motorized land vehicle such as a personal automobile, commercial vehicle, or mechanized agricultural vehicle, except for programs accessed through a separate subscription service, when circumvention is a necessary step to allow the diagnosis, repair, or lawful modification of a vehicle function, where such circumvention does not constitute a violation of applicable law, including without limitation regulations promulgated by the Department of Transportation or the Environmental Protection Agency, and is not accomplished for the purpose of gaining unauthorized access to other copyrighted works. (10) Computer programs that are contained in and control the functioning of a lawfully acquired smartphone or home appliance or home system, such as a refrigerator, thermostat, HVAC, or electrical system, when circumvention is a necessary step to allow the diagnosis, maintenance, or repair of such a device or system, and is not accomplished for the purpose of gaining access to other copyrighted works.
thumb_up
21 likes
S
For purposes of this paragraph (b)(10): (i) The "maintenance" of a device or system is the servicing of the device or system in order to make it work in accordance with its original specifications and any changes to those specifications authorized for that device or system; and
(ii) The "repair" of a device or system is the restoring of the device or system to the state of working in accordance with its original specifications and any changes to those specifications authorized for that device or system. (11) (i) Computer programs, where the circumvention is undertaken on a lawfully acquired device or machine on which the computer program operates, or is undertaken on a computer, computer system, or computer network on which the computer program operates with the authorization of the owner or operator of such computer, computer system, or computer network, solely for the purpose of good-faith security research and does not violate any applicable law, including without limitation the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act of 1986. (ii) For purposes of this paragraph (b)(11), "good-faith security research" means accessing a computer program solely for purposes of good-faith testing, investigation, and/or correction of a security flaw or vulnerability, where such activity is carried out in an environment designed to avoid any harm to individuals or the public, and where the information derived from the activity is used primarily to promote the security or safety of the class of devices or machines on which the computer program operates, or those who use such devices or machines, and is not used or maintained in a manner that facilitates copyright infringement.
thumb_up
15 likes
I
(14) Computer programs that operate 3D printers that employ microchip- reliant technological measures to limit the use of feedstock, when circumvention is accomplished solely for the purpose of using alternative feedstock and not for the purpose of accessing design software, design files, or proprietary data. Related Stories Repair Stories
Roadside Speaker Repair
Repair StoriesRepair that Matters
ActivismWe Sent 40 000 Comments Demanding Reform to the Copyright Office
0 Yorum
Yorum EkleYorum Ekle
1024 İptal Yorum gönder
thumb_up
2 likes
Similar Discussions
-
Chris Jericho on the origins of unique part of his Wizard gimmick
-
Barcelona Transfer News Roundup Barca midfielder set for contract talks Xavi requests board to renew club veteran s contract and more 24 September 2022
-
What happened to Cherry Valentine? Tributes pour in as RuPaul s Drag Race star dies aged 28
-
How to check FIFA 23 player ratings outside the game
-
Inspire Institute of Sport joins hands with NTT Data to support Learning Centre Academics Program
-
8 Tips for Coping With a Diagnosis of PPMS Everyday Health
-
Cardi B Before and After A Self Assured Queen Cardi B s Evolution Through the Years The News Pocket
-
Halloween Monster Maker APK Download for Android
-
Сканворды Крепость APK Download for Android
-
Lundi po sie Koleka Putuma m moire traumatique de l Afrique du Sud Po sie Poesie
-
Guerre en Ukraine Vladimir Poutine aurait assur aupr s d Elon Musk que ses objectifs seraient atteints quoi qu il arrive selon un politologue Vladimir Poutine Elon Musk
-
Netflix lance une formule 5 99 euros par mois ce que l on sait de cette offre avec publicit Connect Netflix
-
Apag n de hornos artesanos los panaderos anuncian paros ante los altos precios de la energ a Apagon Hornos
-
Cr dit Suisse envisage de c der des parts de sa division suisse
-
ACLU asks Supreme Court to invalidate laws banning anti Israel boycotts B Politics B Law Crime
-
Countering Failures Of Imagination Lessons We Learnt From Paul Farmer Paul Farmer Health
-
Wall Street cierra con p u00e9rdidas Tesla a u00f1ade presi u00f3n bajista al Nasdaq Cierre Wall
-
JGOD reveals forgotten Modern Warfare SMG that still melts in Warzone Season 5 Dexerto
-
Disney Dreamlight Valley How to Do Farming The Nerd Stash
-
Hey Pandas What Is Something That You Learned From Lockdown? Closed
-
10 Small Business Statistics You Need to Know in 2022 Updated
-
How to Drop a Pin in Maps on iPhone
-
How to Use App Tracking Transparency on iPhone
-
The 8 Best 8TB External Hard Drives of 2022
-
Adding a PowerPoint Callout to a Slide
-
How to Enable IMAP in Zoho Mail
-
Compare Ford Mustang GT Convertible vs Nissan 370Z Roadster CarBuzz
-
2020 Lexus GS F Performance Engine Horsepower Transmission CarBuzz
-
The Rumored Ferrari F12 Successor Could Have An 800 HP V12 CarBuzz
-
Washing machine shaking violently? Here rsquo s how to fix it Tom s Guide