A
%Begin Connecting All Your Messaging Services Might Be Less Than Helpful GA
S
REGULAR Menu Lifewire Tech for Humans Newsletter! Search Close GO Opinion News > Software & Apps
visibility
704 views
thumb_up
47 likes
N
Ledford has been writing, editing, and fact-checking tech stories since 1994. Her work has appeared in Computerworld, PC Magazine, Information Today, and many others.
thumb_up
16 likes
O
lifewire's fact checking process Tweet Share Email Tweet Share Email Software & Apps Mobile Phones Internet & Security Computers & Tablets Smart Life Home Theater & Entertainment Software & Apps Social Media Streaming Gaming New EU laws will force messaging platforms to work with each other. Apple, and FaceBook won’t want to give up their platform lock-in.Secure interoperability is possible, but not without a total redesign. Jayne Harris / Unsplash The EU may force WhatsApp, Signal, iMessage, and other message services to interoperate. It sounds like a dream, but it could end up a nightmare.
thumb_up
31 likes
A
A new EU law, the Digital Markets Act (DMA), is designed to make it possible for small players to compete against the incumbent giants of the tech industry. One part of this law stipulates that users should be able to send messages to each other, regardless of which messaging app they use. But this could have rather severe consequences in terms of security and privacy, which are—ironically—another focus of the DMA.
thumb_up
15 likes
T
"The greatest difficulty in interoperability is agreeing on a common protocol, common code, and means to integrate the different technologies or build a new technology," global cybersecurity assessor Andy Rogers told Lifewire via email. "We must standardize the technology so that everyone works on the same sheet of music. When you decide to integrate a technology that is standardized with your own, like iMessage did with SMS, you can sometimes end up with a kludge of sorts because you're integrating two technologies that weren't intended for each other."
Lock-In
Messaging platforms are valuable because they have considerable lock-in.
thumb_up
44 likes
J
If you, your friends, and your work contacts all use WhatsApp, for example, there’s no way you’re going to move to Signal. We get around this now by having all the messaging apps on our devices and using whichever we need, depending on who we’re talking to. The DMA would force platform vendors like Apple and Facebook to make their services work with each other.
thumb_up
34 likes
D
The idea is that you could choose to use WhatsApp for its superior group chats but still include iMessage-using contacts in the conversation. They wouldn’t have to install the Facebook-owned app at all. When you decide to integrate a technology that is standardized with your own...
thumb_up
19 likes
I
you can sometimes end up with a kludge of sorts... The problems here are utility and security. Apple, WhatsApp, and Signal all use end-to-end encryption to keep the contents of your messages completely private.
thumb_up
38 likes
E
It is impossible for the platform providers to see your messages. How, then, could encryption survive this interoperability?
thumb_up
25 likes
L
Another problem is that those same platform providers will surely make it as annoying as possible to hook up your various chat accounts. Apple has been willing to pay over $5 million per week to Dutch authorities rather than open its App Store payment system for dating apps. WhatsApp might not be able to see inside your messages, but it sure knows who you send them to, when, and what groups you are a part of.
thumb_up
19 likes
N
You can bet that Apple won’t want its iMessage users’ metadata to be sucked up by Facebook, and you can bet that Facebook won’t want anyone to connect to WhatsApp with any kind of anonymity. By allowing interoperability, you remove the platforms’ lock-in and make them far less valuable to their owners.
Is It Even Possible
iMessage already incorporates SMS into the same app as iMessages, so in theory, it could also support WhatsApp, Telegram, and so on.
thumb_up
0 likes
I
But it wouldn't be pretty. Oleg Magni / Unsplash "Over the weekend, cryptography experts sounded the alarm about this idea, saying that platforms might not be able to do this in a way that leaves messages encrypted," writes tech journalist Casey Newton in his Platformer newsletter.
thumb_up
42 likes
M
"It's clear that, to the extent that there might be a way for services like iMessage and WhatsApp to interoperate and preserve encryption, that way has yet to be invented." Security-wise, it's certainly possible to make encryption interoperable, but it would have to use a common standard. "We already have a fantastic technology that is proven time and time again for encryption," says Rogers. "Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) has been used for almost five decades and is still being used today." It's the security behind the little lock in your web browser's URL bar. But that would require a lot of work to implement.
thumb_up
21 likes
A
Perhaps we'll end up with interoperability, but only with unencrypted messages and only with the minimum of support. And who wants that, apart from the big tech companies the DMA is supposed to tame?
thumb_up
7 likes
H
Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know!
thumb_up
49 likes
N
Get the Latest Tech News Delivered Every Day
Subscribe Tell us why! Other Not enough details Hard to understand Submit More from Lifewire How to Fix It When WhatsApp Isn't Working How to Use Google Chat How to Know If You've Been Blocked on WhatsApp Yahoo Messenger: What Was It & Why Did It Shut Down?
thumb_up
48 likes
S
WhatsApp Encryption: What It Is and How to Use It How to Fix It When WhatsApp Voice Messages Aren't Working Best Free Internet Phone Calls Apps (October 2022) How to Use WhatsApp Privacy Settings How to Use WhatsApp on Your Apple Watch How to Fix It When Facebook Messenger Won’t Load Messages How to Tell When Someone Reads Your Text Message Everything You Need to Know About iPhone SMS & MMS What Is WhatsApp? How to Fix WhatsApp Notifications Not Working How to Track Your Messages With WhatsApp Check Marks How to Check Messages on Instagram Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up Newsletter Sign Up By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts.
thumb_up
7 likes
L
Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies
thumb_up
1 likes
Similar Discussions
-
Today s Heardle Here are clues and answer for Sunday September 25 2022
-
Arsenal Transfer News Roundup Former player backs Gunners to extend William Saliba stay club initiate talks to sign Eintracht Frankfurt winger in January and more September 22 2022
-
These decisions are not easy KL Rahul opens up on the Rishabh Pant vs Dinesh Karthik debate ahead of IND vs AUS 2022 series
-
Charles Leclerc fumes at Ferrari s engineer during F1 Italian GP
-
Ohio teen Christie Mullins bludgeoned to death
-
Bariatric amp Metabolic Institute Treatments Cleveland Clinic
-
UFO Space Adventure APK Download for Android
-
Whack it whip it tap it and APK Download for Android
-
San Antonio News from KENS 5 APK Download for Android
-
Faster Workouts APK Download for Android
-
Meurtre de Lola Je suis persuad que Dahbia a p t les plombs la mort de sa m re $Alchemy Keywords
-
Fulgor de la pintura
-
Crisis energ tica invierno o infierno? Energ a Empresas Energia
-
Why pickleball is America s fastest growing sport Sports
-
Estas son las armas preferidas por las bandas juveniles que preocupan a las autoridades
-
Los mercados mundiales se tambalean La econom u00eda ser u00e1 la siguiente Mercados Mundiales
-
September Nintendo Direct reportedly a Zelda blowout with numerous Switch ports Dexerto
-
Harley Quinn announced for Gotham Knights along with Mr Freeze Clayface Dexerto
-
How to play Splat Zones in Splatoon 3 Anarchy Battles
-
Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 4 Start and Down Time and More
-
Teresa Giudice And Luis Ruelas s Wedding Won t Be Filmed On RHONJ
-
Hey Pandas What Was The Most Awkward Or Illegal Situation You ve Ever Been In? Closed
-
Labour candidate roasted for condescending analysis of millennials and housing crisis
-
Best Apple iMac Deals Get an Apple Desktop for $571 Digital Trends
-
Reels are about to show up in yet another Facebook feature Digital Trends
-
2022 How to Use Apple AirPlay With Sony Bravia Smart TVs?
-
12 Best Free Movie Websites Online October 2022
-
Apple Watch Car Crash Detection Makes It a Life Saving Machine
-
Android 13 News Release Date and Features
-
Connect All Your Home Phones to Your VoIP Service